Move s:viml_builtin_functions to shared file?

Currently s:viml_builtin_functions is defined twice in both py/pycompiler.vim (

Line 825 in edd6a79

    
           let s:viml_builtin_functions = ['abs', 'acos', 'add', 'and', 'append', 'append', 'argc', 'argidx', 'argv', 'argv', 'asin', 'atan', 'atan2', 'browse', 'browsedir', 'bufexists', 'buflisted', 'bufloaded', 'bufname', 'bufnr', 'bufwinnr', 'byte2line', 'byteidx', 'call', 'ceil', 'changenr', 'char2nr', 'cindent', 'clearmatches', 'col', 'complete', 'complete_add', 'complete_check', 'confirm', 'copy', 'cos', 'cosh', 'count', 'cscope_connection', 'cursor', 'cursor', 'deepcopy', 'delete', 'did_filetype', 'diff_filler', 'diff_hlID', 'empty', 'escape', 'eval', 'eventhandler', 'executable', 'exists', 'extend', 'exp', 'expand', 'feedkeys', 'filereadable', 'filewritable', 'filter', 'finddir', 'findfile', 'float2nr', 'floor', 'fmod', 'fnameescape', 'fnamemodify', 'foldclosed', 'foldclosedend', 'foldlevel', 'foldtext', 'foldtextresult', 'foreground', 'function', 'garbagecollect', 'get', 'get', 'getbufline', 'getbufvar', 'getchar', 'getcharmod', 'getcmdline', 'getcmdpos', 'getcmdtype', 'getcwd', 'getfperm', 'getfsize', 'getfontname', 'getftime', 'getftype', 'getline', 'getline', 'getloclist', 'getmatches', 'getpid', 'getpos', 'getqflist', 'getreg', 'getregtype', 'gettabvar', 'gettabwinvar', 'getwinposx', 'getwinposy', 'getwinvar', 'glob', 'globpath', 'has', 'has_key', 'haslocaldir', 'hasmapto', 'histadd', 'histdel', 'histget', 'histnr', 'hlexists', 'hlID', 'hostname', 'iconv', 'indent', 'index', 'input', 'inputdialog', 'inputlist', 'inputrestore', 'inputsave', 'inputsecret', 'insert', 'invert', 'isdirectory', 'islocked', 'items', 'join', 'keys', 'len', 'libcall', 'libcallnr', 'line', 'line2byte', 'lispindent', 'localtime', 'log', 'log10', 'luaeval', 'map', 'maparg', 'mapcheck', 'match', 'matchadd', 'matcharg', 'matchdelete', 'matchend', 'matchlist', 'matchstr', 'max', 'min', 'mkdir', 'mode', 'mzeval', 'nextnonblank', 'nr2char', 'or', 'pathshorten', 'pow', 'prevnonblank', 'printf', 'pumvisible', 'pyeval', 'py3eval', 'range', 'readfile', 'reltime', 'reltimestr', 'remote_expr', 'remote_foreground', 'remote_peek', 'remote_read', 'remote_send', 'remove', 'remove', 'rename', 'repeat', 'resolve', 'reverse', 'round', 'screencol', 'screenrow', 'search', 'searchdecl', 'searchpair', 'searchpairpos', 'searchpos', 'server2client', 'serverlist', 'setbufvar', 'setcmdpos', 'setline', 'setloclist', 'setmatches', 'setpos', 'setqflist', 'setreg', 'settabvar', 'settabwinvar', 'setwinvar', 'sha256', 'shellescape', 'shiftwidth', 'simplify', 'sin', 'sinh', 'sort', 'soundfold', 'spellbadword', 'spellsuggest', 'split', 'sqrt', 'str2float', 'str2nr', 'strchars', 'strdisplaywidth', 'strftime', 'stridx', 'string', 'strlen', 'strpart', 'strridx', 'strtrans', 'strwidth', 'submatch', 'substitute', 'synID', 'synIDattr', 'synIDtrans', 'synconcealed', 'synstack', 'system', 'tabpagebuflist', 'tabpagenr', 'tabpagewinnr', 'taglist', 'tagfiles', 'tempname', 'tan', 'tanh', 'tolower', 'toupper', 'tr', 'trunc', 'type', 'undofile', 'undotree', 'values', 'virtcol', 'visualmode', 'wildmenumode', 'winbufnr', 'wincol', 'winheight', 'winline', 'winnr', 'winrestcmd', 'winrestview', 'winsaveview', 'winwidth', 'writefile', 'xor']

) and js/jscompiler.vim.

I think this should be shared, probably in s:VimLParser.builtin_functions.

It is likely also out of date. It would be good if this could be used through some Vim function directly.

I have created vim/vim#4700 to ask about support in Vim for this.

s:VimLParser.builtin_functions

Yes, currently vimlparser doesn't have such thing.
I want to implement it for #105.

Currently scripts/update_builtin_commands.sh checks vim source (src/ex_cmds.h).
I want to provide similar script for vim functions (parse src/evalfunc.c).

Ok. As per vim/vim#4700 Vim is unlikely to provide this information itself.

However, nvim_get_commands exists already (although only for non-builtin). Might be useful in general, but only for "dynamic" linting/parsing (i.e. not for vint, vimlparser.py etc, which need the list already).

Thanks for asking to vim/vim.
I didn't know nvim_get_commands() (because I'm not neovim user).
currently neovim ex commands is updated manually. it should help auto-update 👍

Does neovim provide function list version of nvim_get_commands() ?

Created #123

I don't read nvim source code, because it MAY results in license violation when I write vim patch.
(@mattn has the same policy)

I don't read nvim source code, because it MAY results in license violation when I write vim patch.
(@mattn has the same policy)

Interesting - can you elaborate?

nvim_get_commands seems to just provide the internal information: https://github.com/neovim/neovim/blob/a46fe2e615bc5f4431cad04b67ac5ba0b67ed86c/src/nvim/api/buffer.c#L653-L684

Interesting - can you elaborate?

Neovim's license is Apache license.
But Vim's license is Vim license.
I don't clearly say they are compatible.

nvim_get_commands seems to just provide the internal information: https://github.com/neovim/neovim/blob/a46fe2e615bc5f4431cad04b67ac5ba0b67ed86c/src/nvim/api/buffer.c#L653-L684

sorry, I can't read it because of above reason 😓
I'm just afraid of that.