wikimedia-gadgets/Edit-Request-Wizard

Extra button on first screen

Closed this issue · 2 comments

Just a single button is needed which does verification and leads user to next screen.

Screenshot 2022-07-30 at 11 56 43 PM

Two buttons makes the UX poorer as you can change the URL and click "Next" without hitting "Verify" (shown above).

Or the other way round:

Screenshot 2022-07-30 at 5 42 35 PM

the concern with a single button was if the source is borderline, the user should have to "confirm" that. I guess we don't have to support that, because borderline sources are a judgment call that beginners aren't equipped to make. although, actually, maybe we want something like "if you can use a different source for this, do so?" but do we make that a hard restriction (so, we'd get rid of the "borderline" category)?

hmm, I see. In that case I think #6 solves the problem in the better way. FWIW I think borderline sources should not be hard disallowed.