WFLW Ground Truth landmark coordinates doubts
cassie101 opened this issue · 0 comments
Hi @wywu, we noticed that some of the points for testing are strangely labeled. For example, in image 20_Family_Group_Family_Group_20_118.jpg, the landmark for point 88 (left inner lips) and 92 (right inner lips) are labelled at the same location.
In your ground truth, this corresponds to element 176,177 and element 184,185 which coordinates are:
'511.903015' '176.186005'
'512.805786' '176.284866'
Are they done intentionally?
This information is taken from list_98pt_test.txt
460.250183 119.457390 460.182925 127.510249 459.524832 135.534806 458.508017 143.523536 458.612313 151.561096 460.432317 159.393538 463.191511 166.958714 466.233100 174.416003 469.346006 181.843946 472.540975 189.236712 476.246950 196.381600 481.083341 202.804774 485.935830 209.201427 489.041375 216.627161 493.190537 223.450792 500.214228 227.244569 508.168759 228.303213 517.255823 227.299277 526.137446 225.097812 534.713523 221.906679 542.897046 217.811551 550.601759 212.874392 557.721266 207.126040 564.126325 200.592164 569.690194 193.328674 574.382879 185.472764 578.252795 177.179518 581.360719 168.570873 583.769538 159.740493 585.540197 150.759816 586.793757 141.691707 587.696223 132.581386 588.421997 123.455002 462.535004 108.564011 469.135010 103.190010 476.015015 102.980003 483.630035 102.798996 490.654999 105.049004 490.475006 109.459000 483.654999 108.198997 475.845001 107.144005 468.975037 107.108994 511.433044 101.483009 525.554016 99.107010 538.833984 99.279808 553.114014 102.077003 565.017029 108.835999 552.888000 107.602989 539.021973 103.716003 525.254028 106.476006 511.147003 108.483002 501.889008 120.973999 498.866633 131.209360 496.331946 141.560868 491.558282 150.787730 486.713013 158.186005 493.663311 159.610807 500.429043 161.314491 510.028485 158.233025 519.361938 155.489105 469.398621 121.840652 474.647341 118.304444 480.800146 116.981446 487.872301 118.523926 493.822998 122.711998 487.552767 125.460749 480.735669 125.807974 474.892448 124.341421 521.302002 122.459999 527.409961 117.157154 535.035023 114.650516 543.701384 116.420714 551.577881 120.603951 543.624904 122.263489 535.553126 123.198412 528.392131 123.538798 481.094330 176.206665 488.334472 170.670319 497.429113 170.160229 504.112890 169.970744 508.685630 169.569725 525.700740 170.291797 542.072021 174.024002 533.540572 188.872838 517.744885 196.498387 500.706750 199.729979 491.416981 194.843728 485.423343 186.004672 511.903015 176.186005 486.262192 178.418047 503.790537 175.248848 536.117056 175.362401 512.805786 176.284866 535.747143 182.982195 502.764955 190.421496 485.906791 176.158220 484.214724 121.413497 540.025767 119.944785 20--Family_Group/20_Family_Group_Family_Group_20_118.jpg
We also noticed similar behavior in other images such as:
2_Demonstration_Protesters_2_486.jpg
41_Swimming_Swimmer_41_358.jpg
12_Group_Team_Organized_Group_12_Group_Team_Organized_Group_12_328.jpg
13_Interview_Interview_Sequences_13_287.jpg
44_Aerobics_Aerobics_44_494.jpg
2_Demonstration_Protesters_2_586.jpg
and others