xarray-contrib/cf-xarray

add `DataArray.cf.get_pyproj_crs()`

larsbuntemeyer opened this issue · 10 comments

larsbuntemeyer commented

Woud be nice to have a cf function that generates CRS from grid_mappings that cartopy can understand for plotting. Would be nice to simply work without having to know which mapping is present, e.g., no need to pick the required cartopy CRS by hand.

Continue the dicussions started here:

Related issues:

larsbuntemeyer commented

For the cartopy case, this seems to have been an issue for some time now.

I am unsure, why this seems to be complicated (also it should not?)...

A possible workaround before going upstream: we could use a couple of mappings that simply map cf grid_mapping_name to the appropriate cartopy CRS (including **kwargs).

trexfeathers commented

Those of us developing Iris are equally frustrated around this topic:

Apologies for my incomplete understanding of this area, I believe the two links I have provided are relevant, although there may be others.

  • 👍1
larsbuntemeyer commented

@dcherian I have some code that i now use regularly to do transformations based on grid mappings using pyproj:

https://github.com/euro-cordex/py-cordex/blob/90e18d1bf020b3b869d9d2ffcc7039a63a92f176/cordex/transform.py#L77-L175

I also use that to compute boundaries by transforming the linear x, y boundaries according to the grid mapping info. I was wondering if that could have a place here in a kind of mapping class, e.g., as an option in _guess_bounds... also pinging @aulemahal here...

dcherian commented

I think the transformations should be in rioxarray already?

cc @snowman2

larsbuntemeyer commented

Ahh, nice! Yes, you mentioned that in the roadmap. I'll check it out.

dcherian commented

FWIW I'd be happy to add .cf.crs -> pyproj.CRS and .cf.crs_cartopy if someone has heuristics for cartopy_crs lying around.

larsbuntemeyer commented

I started something here for ccrs some time ago (it's the naive approach). Would be happy to move something to cf_xarray!

aulemahal commented

Pyproj already has almost everything here https://github.com/pyproj4/pyproj/blob/69fb46f2c007f71a3534a7c935b6f8813a45dfa6/pyproj/crs/_cf1x8.py

When I last looked at this, fixing SciTools/cartopy#2099 really looked like the most elegant way forward... Also, if a naive and explicit mapping from CF to Cartopy is the solution, maybe it would be most useful in cartopy directly ?