[Bug]: left/top won't blend, bottom/right do?
Opened this issue · 11 comments
What happened?
I'm 100% sure this is me doing something wrong, but I am trying to outpaint a portrait I have to give me more headroom for differing aspect ratios. I was able to beautifully extend below and to the right of my original work, but any attempts to outpaint to the left or top of the original image give an absolutely hard border and content that doesn't match up at all. It almost acts like it is drawing content for the right side then placing it on the left if that makes any sense. I'm attaching an example.
Steps to reproduce the problem
- outpaint to the left or above original stamped image
What should have happened?
No seam?
Commit where the problem happens
989a3fa0
What platforms do you use to access openOutpaint?
Windows
What browsers do you use to access the UI ?
Mozilla Firefox
Browser Extensions/Addons
1password, uBlock origin, Video downloader pro
AUTOMATIC1111 webUI Commandline Arguments
--api --medvram
Additional information
No response
Call me crazy but it acts to me like it is only looking at the top left corner of the cursor when looking for existing content to blend with. If the existing content in the cursor is not there, but instead over on the right, it just completely ignores it?
hey, sorry for the delay; yeah, uh outpainting anywhere is definitely an intended use case and there shouldn't be any restrictions on where you're doing so; just to confirm, you're using an inpainting model?
otherwise, if you expand the debug info region of the main menu and click the toggle debug button, it should download an image containing the image content and generated mask upon the next dream - if you'd upload that, it'd be appreciated
It is possible I had somehow changed the model after doing the right side. Not sure how but anything is possible as I am learning this tool.
I will go back to this image and try messing with it again
Is this helpful? Not sure what I am seeing but this is when I was trying to re-roll additional options for a strip across the top because the existing ones were not blending.
yep, thanks; the debug image is 2 images vertically stacked; the top is your existing image with any empty area represented in black, and the bottom is the "mask" to apply in/outpainting to (in white, with existing content in black) so that's exactly as expected for an outpainting operation... for example,
is the debug output for the outpaint generating the lower-right on this image
so tl;dr on that is it seems that the existing image and mask are being passed correctly to the API; did you verify you're using an inpainting model? or maybe did you possibly turn down the overmask value in the dream/img2img context menu? obviously you did not turn down overmask as evidenced by the overmask blobs in your debug image🤦
Yeah verified both settings were correct :( Strangely this time around I was able to do both right and left but top is a mess. Maybe this is just how it is and it is just luck if it works on an image or not :(
well huh... just as a side note, i know i personally don't really do much in the way of, like, "large-scale" outpaints, and seem to have better overall coherence using smaller regions with a lot of context from the existing image... do smaller regions like 512x512 work "better"?
Well the previous images were all too big for a single 512x512 addition to work well because it would miss a lot of context.
That said I continue to refine my workflow (as I think we all do constantly since every hour it seems there are new tools) and I'm going to start doing my outpainting earlier in the process I think, before upressing.
Ok so wanted to come backj to this with a new image I am working on where I am doing the outpainting early in the process while still at lower resolution, as discussed.
You can see here once again where the right side blends in perfect but the left side acts like it completely ignores the content that it overlaps. This is using the 512x512 region.
I expanded the screenshot to show the settings, including that the model is set to an inpainting one, and that the overmask is set.
legit bonkers, seriously. if you're still working on that, can you click the save workspace button
and give it whatever name you'd like, then click the [...] button, export it and upload it? i'd like to see if it worksonmymachine.jpg
similarly, can you try importing the attached workspace and seeing if outpainting works as expected on that?
2023-03-15T23 46 35.786Z_openOutpaint_workspace.zip
assuming the model in your image is runway's, that's the one i'm using here as well
i mean like, maybe your computer's... kinda ethically opposed against westward expansion or something? :P
I could probably recreate the workspace and get to that state. I will note however that I did finally get it to properly outpaint left, by creating a tall rectangle that encompassed the entire left side at once and, not sure it matters, I drew that rectangle from the bottom right (so starting inside the original image) to top left. When I did that it seemed to figure out what the heck I wanted, whereas just doing a standard 512x512 overlapping block in the top left, as shown in the image, did not.