Ephemeral database credentials with Vault and Terraform

Technical demo for the Vancouver Hashicorp User Group spring time meetup.

Requirements

docker-compose https://docs.docker.com/compose/install/#install-compose
terraform https://www.terraform.io/downloads.html
vault https://www.vaultproject.io/downloads.html

This demo has been tested on the following versions; it's not guaranteed that it will work on newer/older ones:

docker-compose 1.23.2 with Compose file format version 3.7 support or greater
terraform version 0.12.7
vault client/server version 1.2.2

Abstract

The idea of this demo is to generate database ephemeral credentials using Hashicorp Vault PostgreSQL Database Secrets Engine.

The demo uses docker-compose to run Vault + PostgreSQL servers locally and the Terraform vault_database_secret_backend to manage all the necessary roles, connections and Vault configuration in a codified way.

In this example we will provision two secret backend roles, one called service-write that would grant database write access to a service and another one called dev-read that would grant read-only access to a developer.

Each role has a different TTL which is the length of the credentials.

Usage

Generating Vault server root token

In production you would authenticate with your Vault server which will result on your VAULT_TOKEN environment variable being set.

For this demo, let's just use an example (insecure) root token and use it for both terraform and docker-compose commands:

# Export VAULT_TOKEN and VAULT_ADDR
export VAULT_TOKEN="insecure_vault_token"
export VAULT_ADDR="http://0.0.0.0:8200"

Starting up docker-compose

First, ensure VAULT_TOKEN is set. This is very important as we pass our generated VAULT_TOKEN to the vault server running on docker-compose.

env | grep VAULT_
# Should return:
VAULT_TOKEN=insecure_vault_token
VAULT_ADDR=http://0.0.0.0:8200

Then just run to start up both the Postgres and Vault server containers:

docker-compose up

Worth noting that this runs in the foreground and that you'll need to open a new terminal to continue the other commands.

Generating credentials

Terraform pre-reqs

Add a file like the following to store database root credentials which will be used by Vault to generate ephemeral ones. While we use the Docker Postgres defaults, it's always a good idea to follow this approach for sensitive information:

terraform.tfvars

db_user = "postgres"
db_password = "password"

This demo will store state on a local file named terraform.tfstate but it's recommended to use a Remote State for real projects. More information on Terraform remote state here.

Terraform init and plan

Run:

terraform init

Then, ensure VAULT_TOKEN and VAULT_ADDR are set, this is to ensure the Vault Terraform Provider is able to interact with your vault server running on docker-compose

env | grep VAULT_
# Should return:
VAULT_TOKEN=insecure_vault_token
VAULT_ADDR=http://0.0.0.0:8200

If the env vars are not present, just export them again:

export VAULT_TOKEN="insecure_vault_token"
export VAULT_ADDR="http://0.0.0.0:8200"

Then run

terraform plan

This should generate an execution plan similar to the following:

Terraform will perform the following actions:

  + vault_database_secret_backend_connection.postgres
      id:                                <computed>
      allowed_roles.#:                   "2"
      allowed_roles.0:                   "service-write"
      allowed_roles.1:                   "dev-read"
      backend:                           "database"
      name:                              "postgres-secret-backend"
      postgresql.#:                      "1"
      postgresql.0.connection_url:       "postgres://postgres:password@database:5432/postgres?sslmode=disable"
      postgresql.0.max_open_connections: "2"
      verify_connection:                 "false"

  + vault_database_secret_backend_role.postgres_dev_read
      id:                                <computed>
      backend:                           "database"
      creation_statements:               REDACTED
      db_name:                           "postgres-secret-backend"
      default_ttl:                       "2592000"
      max_ttl:                           "2592000"
      name:                              "dev-read"
      revocation_statements:             REDACTED

  + vault_database_secret_backend_role.postgres_service_write
      id:                                <computed>
      backend:                           "database"
      creation_statements:               REDACTED
      db_name:                           "postgres-secret-backend"
      default_ttl:                       "864000"
      max_ttl:                           "864000"
      name:                              "service-write"
      revocation_statements:             REDACTED

  + vault_mount.database
      id:                                <computed>
      accessor:                          <computed>
      default_lease_ttl_seconds:         "2592000"
      max_lease_ttl_seconds:             "2592000"
      path:                              "database"
      type:                              "database"


Plan: 4 to add, 0 to change, 0 to destroy.

Terraform apply

If the terraform plan output looks similar to the above one then run:

terraform apply

This will create the resources in Vault.

Trying it out

After applying the changes, we should be able to use vault CLI to interact with our newly created database secret backend:

# Ensure VAULT_TOKEN and VAULT_ADDR are set for this to work!
vault read database/config/postgres-secret-backend

Key                                   Value
---                                   -----
allowed_roles                         [service-write dev-read]
connection_details                    map[connection_url:postgres://postgres:*****@database:5432/postgres?sslmode=disable max_open_connections:2]
plugin_name                           postgresql-database-plugin

Use write credentials

First generate a new set of creds with vault:

vault read database/creds/service-write

Key                Value
---                -----
lease_id           database/creds/service-write/lVpzrysA5akqSvjZVtCgx1i9
lease_duration     240h
lease_renewable    true
password           A1a-9yW06ZdVk54I5KnX
username           v-token-service--1luYzAYl7SdMxvdpibYv-1555972312

Assign DB username and lease to bash variables for later use:

DB_USER_WRITE=(paste the username here)
LEASE_ID_WRITE=(paste the lease_id here)

* Note: You could also append -format=json to the vault command and then parse the fields easily using jq

Then use the returned credentials to login into your local Postgres database and make some changes. Use the password from the vault command above when prompted.

psql -h localhost -U "${DB_USER_WRITE}" -W -d postgres

CREATE TABLE test_table (
             product_no integer,
             name text,
             price numeric
         );
INSERT INTO test_table VALUES (1, 'Cheese', 9.99);

SELECT * FROM test_table;

\dt;

You can also view your newly created user when running \du;

Use read credentials

Generate new read creds and use them:

vault read database/creds/dev-read
Key                Value
---                -----
lease_id           database/creds/dev-read/TLCjNu5vT73r0QCW6X86f26Z
lease_duration     720h
lease_renewable    true
password           A1a-GiwY6h7CHbsMHLLL
username           v-token-analytic-09puAVVxuQm6ELgrIMXT-1555973788

Assign DB username and lease to bash variables for later use:

DB_USER_READ=(paste the username here)
LEASE_ID_READ=(paste the lease_id here)

Then use the returned credentials to login into your local Postgres database and make some changes. Use the password from the vault command above when prompted.

psql -h localhost -U "${DB_USER_READ}" -W -d postgres

# We can SELECT but not INSERT
SELECT * FROM test_table;

INSERT INTO test_table VALUES (2, 'Lettuce', 2.92);
> ERROR:  permission denied for relation test_table

Cleaning up credentials

We can use vault lease revoke to send an asynchronous revocation request before the TTL expires. For example, let's revoke the dev-read credential:

vault lease revoke "${LEASE_ID_READ}"
All revocation operations queued successfully!

Check the vault logs on docker-compose stdout to ensure it actually gets revoked:

vault_1     | [INFO]  expiration: revoked lease: lease_id=database/creds/dev-read/TLCjNu5vT73r0QCW6X86f26Z

# Run postgres \du; command using root - postgres user password is "password"
psql -h localhost -U postgres -W -d postgres -c "\du;"

If you actually attempt to revoke the service-write user, it won't let you as its the owner of the test_table relation, even if vault lease revoke won't directly return an error:

vault lease revoke "${LEASE_ID_WRITE}"
All revocation operations queued successfully!

# Error seen in docker-compose stdout:
vault_1     | [ERROR] expiration: failed to revoke lease: 
lease_id=database/creds/service-write/lVpzrysA5akqSvjZVtCgx1i9 error="failed to revoke entry: resp: (*logical.Response)(nil) err: pq: cannot be dropped because some objects depend on it"

In order for this revocation to succeed, you'd need to DROP the test_table first:

# postgres user password is "password"
psql -h localhost -U postgres -W -d postgres -c "DROP TABLE test_table;"
DROP TABLE

# Revocation working now:
vault lease revoke "${LEASE_ID_WRITE}"
All revocation operations queued successfully!

vault_1     | [INFO]  expiration: revoked lease: lease_id=database/creds/service-write/lVpzrysA5akqSvjZVtCgx1i9

That's why it's a good idea to use PostgreSQL role inheritance to avoid objects being owned by individual users and using shared roles instead. Further reading here.

Cleaning up the infrastructure

terraform destroy
docker-compose down

If there are any leases pending, Vault will try to revoke them first so keep in mind the Postgres object ownership point above.

BenchLabs/talk-vault-ephemeral-credentials