JiaLiPassion/angular-elements-with-zone

AngularElements

A POC of Angular Elements with zone.js.

In ng-conf 2018, robwormald described the use cases of Angular Elements.

1. If the Angular Elements is used inside an Angular application, then zone.js is already loaded, so user can develop the Angular Elements in normal way.

   • Pro: User can develop Angular Element just like they develop normal Angular Component, and user can easily expose a lot of existing Angular Component to Angular Element.
   • Con: In this case, there is a limitation that the Angular Element need to run in a Angular App Host.

2. If the Angular Elements is used inside an non-angular application, such as inside a web app which developed with pure js or jquery or react, then we should not use zone.js, because zone.js will monkey-patch a lot of global/window APIs such as setTimeout/Promise, so using zone.js will impact the APIs outside of Angular Elements. Instead, we use noop zone.

   • Pro: Don't need to worry about zone.js, no Window API will be patched, and the bundle size is smaller (zone.js will be 12k).
   • Con: User need to take care of Change Detection themselves, and existing Angular Component will not be easily exported as Angular Element in this way.

So my idea is add a 3rd option.

3. if there is a way to let zone.js only patch global/window APIs when we enter Angular Elements and restore the original delegate when we exit Angular Elements. We can develop Angular Elements with zone.js without impact outside world.
   • Pro: Still has ngZone, user can still develop Angular Element just like developing normal Angular Component. And of course, the existing Angular Component can easily be exported as Angular Element. And user don't need to worry about zone.js will impact other parts of the webapp which are outside of Angular Element.
   • Con: User still need to load zone.js, which will be 12k bundle.

This is the overview

How it works

1. First import zone.js/dist/zone.js will not monkey-patch anything until Zone.__init__() is called.
2. Call Zone.__init__() before bootstrap Angular Elements.
3. After BootStrap, restore all monkey-patched APIs to native one.

try {
  Zone.__init__(); // monkey patch window APIs
  platformBrowserDynamic()
    .bootstrapModule(AppModule)
    .then(ref => {
      // Ensure Angular destroys itself on hot reloads.
      if (window['ngRef']) {
        window['ngRef'].destroy();
      }
      window['ngRef'] = ref;

      // Otherise, log the boot error
    })
    .catch(err => console.error(err));
} finally {
  Zone.__unloadAll_patch(); // detach the monkey patch, so all window APIs was restored to native one.
}

4. Inside zone.run()/zone.runGuarded(), reload all patches before run and unload all patches after run.

So monkey patched version of window API only exists inside Angular Elements

Here is the demo link DEMO.

In the demo, there is an angular Element with zone.js, and it will run inside of angular zone, and outside there is a button Click outside of Angular Element, click the button will check eventHandler/setTimeout/Promise is monkey patched or not, and print error stack traces to verify no zone related stack frames are inside.