emacs-evil/evil-surround

Unexpected interaction with evil-embrace on Doom Emacs

Opened this issue · 2 comments

countvajhula commented

Hi there,
I'm bringing this issue to your attention that was reported on the Symex repo, in case you feel a fix is warranted in evil-surround. It appears that Doom Emacs enables some advice by default that leads to unexpected interaction between evil-surround and evil-embrace.

I personally am not experiencing this issue but it seems that it affects (all?) Doom Emacs users.

Reproducing it:

(f1 |(x1 x2))

M-: (evil-surround-change (following-char))

Causes:

Debugger entered--Lisp error: (error "No surrounding delimiters found")
  error("No surrounding delimiters found")
  evil-select-paren("( " " )" 1847 1847 nil 1 t)
  evil-surround-outer-overlay(("( " . " )") 40)
  evil-embrace-evil-surround-change(40)
  apply(evil-embrace-evil-surround-change 40)
  evil-surround-change(40)
  eval-expression((evil-surround-change (following-char)) nil nil 127)
  funcall-interactively(eval-expression (evil-surround-change (following-char)) nil nil 127)
  command-execute(eval-expression)

for affected users.

countvajhula commented

Looks like there is an existing issue on evil-embrace that may be connected: cute-jumper/evil-embrace.el#12

tomdl89 commented

Thanks for raising @countvajhula . As evil-embrace aims to be "making evil-surround even better" my initial take is to let them investigate. If there's a bug in evil-surround that's uncovered by evil-embrace doing an otherwise sensible thing, I'm happy to fix.

  • 👍1