PBRMaterialModels

Code for my bachelor thesis "Comparison of material models in modern physically based rendering pipelines", submitted in August 2020 at the Stuttgart Media University

Introduction

To investigate how the PBR material models of the chosen rendering tools differ in terms of the quality and range of reproducible materials, several images depicting an object with different material properties in a certain lighting condition were generated. The material property is influenced by exactly one parameter at a time. Each time the value of the parameter is incremented with a specific step size, a new image is created. This results in a row of images for each rendering tool, which are contrasted in a table, also referred to as material chart.

Within the context of my paper, four material parameters are examined in more detail (Roughness, Specular, Metallic, Clearcoat). The so far examined shader models are:

the “Principled BSDF” in Blender
the “Standard Surface” shader in Arnold
the “Default Lit” or “Clear Coat” model (to evaluate Clearcoat respectively) in the Unreal Engine

General setup

In general, the rendering framework is controlled via command line. The user can specify an arbitrary parameter name and HDRi image for IBL (if the source image is provided in the appropriate folder).

The general syntax is: renderer projectscene pythonscript [renderengine] parameter environment-name

However, the actual syntax differs between each software tool.

The command will execute a Python program that will change the material properties and render the scene afterwards. All references such as path names or the name of the material are defined in the Python scripts. If there are any questions, feel free to ask.

Maya

mayapy python-script scene parameter environment-name

I have used two batch scripts for conventiently rendering scenes:

mayaStandalone_AllEnvironments.bat: scene with IBL (scene must include at least one AiSkyDome) - render the scene with all possible HDRi background images, provided in the respective folder (see mayaStandalone_RenderMatParam.py, l. 17)
mayaStandalone_DirectionalLight.bat: scene without IBL

Blender

blender -b scene -P python-script render-engine parameter environment-name

Again, I have used two batch scripts for conventiently rendering scenes:

blender_AllEnvironments.bat: scene with IBL (will change background of scene via world settings) - render the scene with all possible HDRi background images, provided in the respective folder (see blender_RenderMatParam.py, l. 17)
blender_DirectionalLight.bat: scene without IBL

Unreal Engine

In this case, the logic is partly implemented in blueprints and partly in the provided Python script. If requested, I can provide the Unreal project including the blueprints as well.

The taken approach was to start the application (i.e. game), increment the chosen material parameter while in game mode, render the scene by taking a “high resolution screenshot” and automatically stop the application when the last value has been rendered.