Which is the fastest?
This project aims to be a load benchmarking suite, no more, no less
Measuring response times (routing times) for each framework (middleware).
Results are not production-ready yet
Additional purposes :
- Helping decide between languages, depending on use case
- Learning languages, best practices, devOPS culture ...
- Having fun ❤️
Requirements
- Crystal as
built-intools are made in this language - Docker as frameworks are
isolatedinto containers - wrk as benchmarking tool,
>= 4.1.0
ℹ️ you need wrk stable
git clone --branch 4.1.0 https://github.com/wg/wrkdocker is used for development purpose, production results will be computed on DigitalOcean
Usage
- Install all dependencies
shards install- Build internal tools
shards build- Build containers
jobs are either languages (example : crystal) or frameworks (example : router.cr)
bin/neph [job1] [job2] [job3] ...- Start the benchmark ....
tools is a list of language / framework to challenge (example : ruby kemal amber go python)
bin/benchmarker [tools]Results
Last update: 2019 March 01
OS: Linux (version: 4.16.3-301.fc28.x86_64, arch: x86_64)
CPU Cores: 8
Latency
Ranking (top 5)
1️⃣ nickel (rust)
2️⃣ roda (ruby)
3️⃣ rack-routing (ruby)
4️⃣ slim (php)
5️⃣ laravel (php)
Full table
| Language (Runtime) | Framework (Middleware) | Average | 50th percentile | 90th percentile | 99th percentile | 99.9th percentile | Standard deviation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| rust (1.32) | nickel (0.11) | 0.08 ms | 0.09 ms | 0.12 ms | 0.16 ms | 5.88 ms | 57.33 |
| ruby (2.6) | roda (3.17) | 3.63 ms | 0.19 ms | 13.57 ms | 35.98 ms | 95.17 ms | 7781.67 |
| ruby (2.6) | rack-routing (0.0) | 4.56 ms | 0.24 ms | 17.34 ms | 41.14 ms | 101.54 ms | 9268.33 |
| php (7.3) | slim (3.12) | 155.57 ms | 0.37 ms | 260.18 ms | 3492.86 ms | 6708.36 ms | 578721.33 |
| php (7.3) | laravel (5.8) | 125.50 ms | 0.37 ms | 297.81 ms | 2405.81 ms | 6901.47 ms | 458184.67 |
| ruby (2.6) | flame (4.18) | 6.96 ms | 0.40 ms | 24.27 ms | 53.37 ms | 133.02 ms | 12338.00 |
| rust (1.32) | iron (0.6) | 0.40 ms | 0.40 ms | 0.62 ms | 0.96 ms | 12.30 ms | 224.33 |
| ruby (2.6) | hanami (1.3) | 7.43 ms | 0.42 ms | 26.23 ms | 53.66 ms | 130.79 ms | 12893.33 |
| ruby (2.6) | sinatra (2.0) | 8.87 ms | 0.55 ms | 28.98 ms | 58.68 ms | 132.30 ms | 14053.67 |
| rust (nightly) | rocket (0.4) | 114.21 ms | 1.76 ms | 4.29 ms | 3738.32 ms | 6593.28 ms | 622620.00 |
| php (7.3) | zend-framework (3.1) | 147.42 ms | 1.93 ms | 286.76 ms | 2935.34 ms | 6375.14 ms | 539996.00 |
| php (7.3) | lumen (5.7) | 146.90 ms | 2.25 ms | 278.24 ms | 3269.41 ms | 6774.79 ms | 533011.67 |
| php (7.3) | symfony (4.2) | 97.29 ms | 2.44 ms | 204.93 ms | 2171.42 ms | 5729.07 ms | 401643.33 |
| php (7.3) | zend-expressive (3.2) | 110.12 ms | 2.46 ms | 229.31 ms | 2463.01 ms | 5013.13 ms | 413493.00 |
| rust (1.32) | actix-web (0.7) | 3.69 ms | 2.79 ms | 7.99 ms | 16.77 ms | 36.59 ms | 3491.67 |
| python (3.7) | japronto (0.1) | 3.61 ms | 2.89 ms | 7.12 ms | 15.43 ms | 35.06 ms | 3235.67 |
| ruby (2.6) | rails (5.2) | 39.21 ms | 2.95 ms | 131.87 ms | 368.77 ms | 1075.92 ms | 78130.67 |
| c (99) | kore (3.1) | 6.47 ms | 3.23 ms | 7.87 ms | 45.88 ms | 722.37 ms | 29991.00 |
| python (3.6) | vibora (0.0) | 4.64 ms | 3.67 ms | 9.38 ms | 17.50 ms | 49.15 ms | 3772.33 |
| c (11) | agoo-c (0.3) | 3.84 ms | 3.91 ms | 6.43 ms | 8.57 ms | 33.94 ms | 2043.67 |
| go (1.11) | fasthttprouter (0.1) | 4.34 ms | 3.98 ms | 6.75 ms | 14.13 ms | 62.49 ms | 2659.00 |
| crystal (0.27) | onyx (0.6) | 4.38 ms | 4.16 ms | 7.44 ms | 14.19 ms | 33.37 ms | 2751.33 |
| cpp (11.0) | evhtp (1.2) | 3.82 ms | 4.21 ms | 5.54 ms | 8.05 ms | 90.15 ms | 2275.33 |
| rust (1.32) | gotham (0.3) | 4.94 ms | 4.41 ms | 9.23 ms | 20.08 ms | 159.88 ms | 4853.67 |
| ruby (2.6) | agoo (2.8) | 6.36 ms | 4.49 ms | 10.91 ms | 50.51 ms | 121.06 ms | 8911.67 |
| crystal (0.27) | spider-gazelle (1.4) | 5.36 ms | 4.50 ms | 10.16 ms | 21.39 ms | 70.27 ms | 4376.33 |
| nim (0.19) | jester (0.4) | 5.24 ms | 5.21 ms | 7.96 ms | 14.17 ms | 38.54 ms | 2720.67 |
| node (11.10) | restana (2.9) | 6.62 ms | 5.22 ms | 9.99 ms | 20.35 ms | 257.44 ms | 7853.67 |
| node (11.10) | rayo (1.2) | 7.28 ms | 5.53 ms | 10.74 ms | 21.89 ms | 326.25 ms | 9857.67 |
| node (11.10) | polka (0.5) | 7.14 ms | 5.54 ms | 10.87 ms | 22.48 ms | 263.29 ms | 7923.67 |
| java (8) | act (1.8) | 6.50 ms | 5.73 ms | 10.68 ms | 21.32 ms | 193.64 ms | 5019.67 |
| go (1.11) | iris (11.1) | 7.29 ms | 5.73 ms | 11.59 ms | 23.87 ms | 304.14 ms | 8735.67 |
| go (1.11) | muxie (1.0) | 7.16 ms | 5.82 ms | 12.11 ms | 24.04 ms | 108.50 ms | 4489.67 |
| go (1.11) | chi (4.0) | 7.31 ms | 5.95 ms | 12.24 ms | 24.41 ms | 152.05 ms | 4522.33 |
| csharp (7.3) | aspnetcore (2.2) | 7.19 ms | 6.02 ms | 9.78 ms | 19.71 ms | 426.52 ms | 11793.00 |
| go (1.11) | kami (2.2) | 7.68 ms | 6.40 ms | 12.60 ms | 25.04 ms | 57.70 ms | 4384.00 |
| go (1.11) | gin (1.3) | 7.94 ms | 6.48 ms | 13.45 ms | 26.16 ms | 141.34 ms | 5134.33 |
| go (1.11) | beego (1.11) | 8.03 ms | 6.55 ms | 13.37 ms | 27.02 ms | 219.42 ms | 5868.33 |
| go (1.11) | echo (4.0) | 8.24 ms | 6.58 ms | 13.80 ms | 28.21 ms | 187.67 ms | 7105.67 |
| go (1.11) | gorilla-mux (1.7) | 8.50 ms | 6.91 ms | 14.17 ms | 28.28 ms | 236.03 ms | 7776.33 |
| scala (2.12) | akkahttp (10.1) | 193.65 ms | 7.70 ms | 62.78 ms | 4676.68 ms | 7923.04 ms | 810306.33 |
| node (11.10) | foxify (0.10) | 8.87 ms | 8.08 ms | 13.98 ms | 26.16 ms | 313.02 ms | 9906.33 |
| python (3.7) | falcon (1.4) | 10.29 ms | 8.34 ms | 18.85 ms | 38.58 ms | 411.23 ms | 12645.33 |
| node (11.10) | fastify (2.0) | 12.41 ms | 8.61 ms | 15.93 ms | 88.41 ms | 604.14 ms | 27218.67 |
| node (11.10) | koa (2.7) | 10.04 ms | 8.71 ms | 14.79 ms | 34.04 ms | 422.32 ms | 13842.67 |
| node (11.10) | muneem (2.4) | 12.90 ms | 8.91 ms | 18.79 ms | 87.45 ms | 640.40 ms | 28081.67 |
| python (3.7) | bottle (0.12) | 11.61 ms | 9.19 ms | 21.77 ms | 43.71 ms | 287.87 ms | 9921.00 |
| node (11.10) | express (4.16) | 12.67 ms | 9.73 ms | 18.12 ms | 52.89 ms | 541.11 ms | 20771.00 |
| go (1.11) | gf (1.5) | 11.06 ms | 9.84 ms | 16.46 ms | 34.38 ms | 314.19 ms | 8879.00 |
| node (11.10) | restify (8.0) | 11.74 ms | 9.93 ms | 16.15 ms | 38.02 ms | 327.76 ms | 10875.33 |
| python (3.7) | hug (2.4) | 16.73 ms | 11.82 ms | 36.41 ms | 64.99 ms | 220.72 ms | 13722.00 |
| python (3.7) | starlette (0.11) | 14.46 ms | 12.47 ms | 24.83 ms | 41.30 ms | 107.54 ms | 7782.33 |
| swift (4.2) | perfect (3.0) | 12.74 ms | 12.95 ms | 14.79 ms | 17.19 ms | 44.86 ms | 1990.33 |
| swift (4.2) | vapor (3.2) | 22.21 ms | 13.43 ms | 24.34 ms | 298.12 ms | 1397.30 ms | 70670.67 |
| scala (2.12) | http4s (0.18) | 16.33 ms | 13.72 ms | 27.61 ms | 49.81 ms | 879.32 ms | 26285.00 |
| python (3.7) | bocadillo (0.12) | 19.03 ms | 17.70 ms | 30.86 ms | 45.51 ms | 98.65 ms | 8889.00 |
| python (3.7) | fastapi (0.6) | 21.80 ms | 18.78 ms | 37.17 ms | 54.81 ms | 104.09 ms | 11018.33 |
| python (3.7) | aiohttp (3.5) | 25.50 ms | 21.14 ms | 48.87 ms | 68.11 ms | 97.62 ms | 15221.33 |
| node (11.10) | hapi (18.1) | 33.94 ms | 23.19 ms | 38.71 ms | 368.08 ms | 1256.70 ms | 72155.00 |
| swift (4.2) | kitura (2.5) | 32.27 ms | 24.71 ms | 43.82 ms | 181.84 ms | 1078.48 ms | 51833.33 |
| crystal (0.27) | router.cr (0.2) | 27.83 ms | 24.98 ms | 38.72 ms | 49.04 ms | 240.45 ms | 9221.33 |
| python (3.7) | molten (0.7) | 35.13 ms | 25.52 ms | 70.65 ms | 99.27 ms | 271.21 ms | 23309.00 |
| crystal (0.27) | raze (0.3) | 28.52 ms | 26.01 ms | 37.52 ms | 48.02 ms | 394.14 ms | 12327.00 |
| python (3.7) | flask (1.0) | 38.06 ms | 29.86 ms | 52.21 ms | 261.73 ms | 585.71 ms | 40266.67 |
| crystal (0.27) | lucky (0.11) | 33.97 ms | 30.76 ms | 49.03 ms | 66.34 ms | 396.86 ms | 15802.00 |
| crystal (0.27) | kemal (0.25) | 32.24 ms | 32.88 ms | 42.63 ms | 50.33 ms | 210.63 ms | 10312.67 |
| crystal (0.27) | orion (1.6) | 41.11 ms | 34.18 ms | 51.54 ms | 178.62 ms | 575.66 ms | 36108.00 |
| crystal (0.27) | amber (0.11) | 35.61 ms | 34.23 ms | 48.10 ms | 58.16 ms | 481.05 ms | 18108.67 |
| python (3.7) | sanic (18.12) | 50.09 ms | 42.33 ms | 94.77 ms | 174.86 ms | 336.31 ms | 35906.67 |
| python (3.7) | quart (0.8) | 57.95 ms | 52.37 ms | 95.58 ms | 134.05 ms | 187.94 ms | 27375.67 |
| python (3.7) | django (2.1) | 59.04 ms | 56.85 ms | 70.96 ms | 126.64 ms | 718.70 ms | 29334.67 |
| python (3.7) | responder (1.3) | 77.97 ms | 70.06 ms | 132.80 ms | 174.52 ms | 287.66 ms | 37169.67 |
| python (3.7) | tornado (5.1) | 88.75 ms | 88.67 ms | 113.16 ms | 134.23 ms | 498.66 ms | 22226.33 |
Requests per seconds
Ranking (top 5)
1️⃣ (japronto) (python)
2️⃣ (actix-web) (rust)
3️⃣ (agoo-c) (c)
4️⃣ (kore) (c)
5️⃣ (evhtp) (cpp)
Full table
| Language (Runtime) | Framework (Middleware) | Requests / s | Throughput |
|---|---|---|---|
| python (3.7) | japronto (0.1) | 278765.00 | 333.82 MB |
| rust (1.32) | actix-web (0.7) | 277726.33 | 315.84 MB |
| c (11) | agoo-c (0.3) | 256969.00 | 148.14 MB |
| c (99) | kore (3.1) | 238152.33 | 619.01 MB |
| cpp (11.0) | evhtp (1.2) | 230709.67 | 223.98 MB |
| python (3.6) | vibora (0.0) | 230566.00 | 261.83 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | onyx (0.6) | 214658.33 | 201.62 MB |
| go (1.11) | fasthttprouter (0.1) | 212598.33 | 341.88 MB |
| rust (1.32) | gotham (0.3) | 206167.33 | 422.02 MB |
| nim (0.19) | jester (0.4) | 200078.33 | 401.88 MB |
| java (8) | act (1.8) | 199296.00 | 389.38 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | spider-gazelle (1.4) | 189826.00 | 202.29 MB |
| ruby (2.6) | agoo (2.8) | 185700.00 | 107.29 MB |
| node (11.10) | restana (2.9) | 151984.00 | 227.23 MB |
| rust (1.32) | iron (0.6) | 148058.00 | 186.65 MB |
| node (11.10) | rayo (1.2) | 140927.67 | 211.03 MB |
| node (11.10) | polka (0.5) | 140478.00 | 210.35 MB |
| csharp (7.3) | aspnetcore (2.2) | 139048.00 | 226.56 MB |
| go (1.11) | iris (11.1) | 138972.67 | 186.35 MB |
| go (1.11) | muxie (1.0) | 135826.33 | 181.93 MB |
| go (1.11) | chi (4.0) | 133324.67 | 178.57 MB |
| go (1.11) | kami (2.2) | 128629.00 | 170.63 MB |
| go (1.11) | gin (1.3) | 124206.33 | 218.14 MB |
| go (1.11) | beego (1.11) | 122935.67 | 165.71 MB |
| go (1.11) | echo (4.0) | 122391.67 | 215.01 MB |
| go (1.11) | gorilla-mux (1.7) | 117398.67 | 157.07 MB |
| node (11.10) | foxify (0.10) | 114828.33 | 240.98 MB |
| node (11.10) | fastify (2.0) | 113817.33 | 278.23 MB |
| python (3.7) | falcon (1.4) | 105946.33 | 272.32 MB |
| node (11.10) | koa (2.7) | 105725.00 | 223.86 MB |
| node (11.10) | muneem (2.4) | 104843.33 | 157.01 MB |
| rust (1.32) | nickel (0.11) | 93604.00 | 186.24 MB |
| go (1.11) | gf (1.5) | 91970.67 | 139.41 MB |
| python (3.7) | bottle (0.12) | 91445.00 | 225.36 MB |
| node (11.10) | express (4.16) | 88783.33 | 217.48 MB |
| node (11.10) | restify (8.0) | 88618.00 | 155.58 MB |
| swift (4.2) | perfect (3.0) | 78114.67 | 73.48 MB |
| php (7.3) | symfony (4.2) | 74838.00 | 372.12 MB |
| python (3.7) | starlette (0.11) | 69945.33 | 150.82 MB |
| php (7.3) | zend-expressive (3.2) | 69506.33 | 345.69 MB |
| scala (2.12) | akkahttp (10.1) | 69211.67 | 148.52 MB |
| php (7.3) | zend-framework (3.1) | 69201.00 | 343.70 MB |
| scala (2.12) | http4s (0.18) | 68209.00 | 119.30 MB |
| python (3.7) | hug (2.4) | 66776.67 | 165.65 MB |
| php (7.3) | slim (3.12) | 65902.67 | 327.06 MB |
| swift (4.2) | vapor (3.2) | 65864.67 | 110.19 MB |
| php (7.3) | lumen (5.7) | 63752.67 | 331.39 MB |
| python (3.7) | bocadillo (0.12) | 52601.67 | 101.64 MB |
| php (7.3) | laravel (5.8) | 49569.67 | 258.32 MB |
| rust (nightly) | rocket (0.4) | 49413.33 | 78.45 MB |
| python (3.7) | fastapi (0.6) | 46468.00 | 100.49 MB |
| python (3.7) | aiohttp (3.5) | 41930.00 | 95.15 MB |
| node (11.10) | hapi (18.1) | 40613.00 | 105.26 MB |
| ruby (2.6) | roda (3.17) | 35618.00 | 34.00 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | router.cr (0.2) | 35377.67 | 33.19 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | raze (0.3) | 35094.00 | 32.89 MB |
| swift (4.2) | kitura (2.5) | 34840.33 | 64.63 MB |
| python (3.7) | molten (0.7) | 32160.33 | 59.85 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | kemal (0.25) | 30858.33 | 50.26 MB |
| python (3.7) | flask (1.0) | 29244.33 | 72.09 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | lucky (0.11) | 29041.33 | 35.68 MB |
| ruby (2.6) | rack-routing (0.0) | 28182.33 | 16.27 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | amber (0.11) | 28061.00 | 51.28 MB |
| crystal (0.27) | orion (1.6) | 25648.00 | 41.79 MB |
| python (3.7) | sanic (18.12) | 21389.00 | 38.12 MB |
| ruby (2.6) | flame (4.18) | 18349.33 | 10.61 MB |
| python (3.7) | quart (0.8) | 17298.00 | 34.44 MB |
| ruby (2.6) | hanami (1.3) | 17171.33 | 130.10 MB |
| python (3.7) | django (2.1) | 16754.67 | 48.56 MB |
| ruby (2.6) | sinatra (2.0) | 14379.67 | 37.36 MB |
| python (3.7) | responder (1.3) | 12817.00 | 27.94 MB |
| python (3.7) | tornado (5.1) | 10993.33 | 32.48 MB |
| ruby (2.6) | rails (5.2) | 3269.67 | 10.06 MB |
How to contribute ?
In any way you want ...
- Request a framework addition
- Report a bug (on any implementation)
- Suggest an idea
- ...
Any kind of idea is ❤️
Contributors
- Taichiro Suzuki - Author, maintainer
- OvermindDL1 - Maintainer
- Marwan Rabbâa - Maintainer
This repository contains a clean copy of the-benchmarker/web-frameworks based on GIT COMMIT: 817e4e1bf96437ada09f0dfd699feb7e028b2817.