proxy-memoize

Intuitive magical memoization library with Proxy and WeakMap

Project status

The API is complete. Unless we find some major issues, it will be fixed. Before reaching v1, we would like to collect more bug reports and best practices. There are no obvious/known issues at the moment, but there are some limitations and workarounds.

Introduction

In frontend framework like React, object immutability is important. JavaScript itself doesn't support forcing immutability. Several libraries help encouraging immutable coding style, like immer. While immer helps updating an object, this library helps creating a derived value from an object, a.k.a. selector.

This library utilizes Proxy and WeakMap, and provides memoization. The memoized function will re-evaluate the original function only if the used part of argument (object) is changed. It's intuitive in a sense and magical in another sense.

How it works

When it (re-)evaluates a function, it will wrap an input object with proxies (recursively, on demand) and invoke the function. When it's finished it will check what is "affected". The "affected" is a list of paths of the input object that are accessed during the function invocation.

Next time when it receives a new input object, it will check if values in "affected" paths are changed. If so, it will re-evaluate the function. Otherwise, it will return a cached result.

The cache size is 1 by default, but configurable.

We have 2-tier cache mechanism. What is described so far is the second tier cache.

The first tier cache is with WeakMap. It's a WeakMap of the input object and the result of function invocation. There's no notion of cache size.

In summary, there are two types of cache:

tier-1: WeakMap based cache (size=infinity)
tier-2: Proxy based cache (size=1, configurable)

Install

npm install proxy-memoize

How it behaves

import memoize from 'proxy-memoize';

const fn = memoize(x => ({ sum: x.a + x.b, diff: x.a - x.b }));

fn({ a: 2, b: 1, c: 1 }); // ---> { sum: 3, diff: 1 }
fn({ a: 3, b: 1, c: 1 }); // ---> { sum: 4, diff: 2 }
fn({ a: 3, b: 1, c: 9 }); // ---> { sum: 4, diff: 2 } (returning a cached value)
fn({ a: 4, b: 1, c: 9 }); // ---> { sum: 5, diff: 3 }

fn({ a: 1, b: 2 }) === fn({ a: 1, b: 2 }); // ---> true

Usage with React Context

Instead of bare useMemo.

const Component = (props) => {
  const [state, dispatch] = useContext(MyContext);
  const render = useCallback(memoize(([props, state]) => (
    <div>
      {/* render with props and state */}
    </div>
  )), [dispatch]);
  return render([props, state]);
};

const App = ({ children }) => (
  <MyContext.Provider value={useReducer(reducer, initialState)}>
    {children}
  </MyContext.Provider>
);

CodeSandbox

Usage with React Redux

Instead of reselect.

import { useSelector } from 'react-redux';

const getScore = memoize(state => ({
  score: heavyComputation(state.a + state.b),
  createdAt: Date.now(),
}));

const Component = ({ id }) => {
  const { score, title } = useSelector(useCallback(memoize(state => ({
    score: getScore(state),
    title: state.titles[id],
  })), [id]));
  return <div>{score.score} {score.createdAt} {title}</div>;
};

Using `size` option

The example above might seem tricky to create memoized selector in component. Alternatively, we can use size option.

import { useSelector } from 'react-redux';

const getScore = memoize(state => ({
  score: heavyComputation(state.a + state.b),
  createdAt: Date.now(),
}));

const selector = memoize(([state, id]) => ({
  score: getScore(state),
  title: state.titles[id],
}), {
  size: 500,
});

const Component = ({ id }) => {
  const { score, title } = useSelector(state => selector([state, id]));
  return <div>{score.score} {score.createdAt} {title}</div>;
};

The drawback of this approach is we need a good estimate of size in advance.

Usage with Zustand

For derived values.

import create from 'zustand';

const useStore = create(set => ({
  valueA,
  valueB,
  // ...
}));

const getDerivedValueA = memoize(state => heavyComputation(state.valueA))
const getDerivedValueB = memoize(state => heavyComputation(state.valueB))
const getTotal = state => getDerivedValueA(state) + getDerivedValueB(state)

const Component = () => {
  const total = useStore(getTotal)
  return <div>{total}</div>;
};

CodeSandbox

API

memoize

Create a memoized function

Parameters

fn function (obj: Obj): Result
options {size: number?}?

Examples

import memoize from 'proxy-memoize';

const fn = memoize(obj => ({ sum: obj.a + obj.b, diff: obj.a - obj.b }));

Returns function (obj: Obj): Result

getUntrackedObject

This is to unwrap a proxy object and return an original object. It returns null if not relevant.

[Notes] This function is for debugging purpose. It's not supposed to be used in production and it's subject to change.

Examples

import memoize, { getUntrackedObject } from 'proxy-memoize';

const fn = memoize(obj => {
  console.log(getUntrackedObject(obj));
  return { sum: obj.a + obj.b, diff: obj.a - obj.b };
});

Limitations and workarounds

Inside the function, objects are wrapped by proxies and touching a property will record it.

const fn = memoize(obj => {
  console.log(obj.c); // this will mark ".c" as used
  return { sum: obj.a + obj.b, diff: obj.a - obj.b };
});

A workaround is to unwrap a proxy.

const fn = memoize(obj => {
  console.log(getUntrackedObject(obj).c);
  return { sum: obj.a + obj.b, diff: obj.a - obj.b };
});

Memoized function will unwrap proxies in the return value only if it consists of plain objects/arrays.

const fn = memoize(obj => {
  return { x: obj.a, y: { z: [obj.b, obj.c] } }; // plain objects
});

In this case above, the return value is clean, however, see the following.

const fn = memoize(obj => {
  return { x: new Set([obj.a]), y: new Map([['z', obj.b]]) }; // not plain
});

We can't unwrap Set/Map or other non-plain objects. The problem is when obj.a is an object (which will be wrapped by a proxy) and touching its property will record the usage, which leads unexpected behavior. If obj.a is a primitive value, there's no problem.

There's no workaround. Please be advised to use only plain objects/arrays. Nested objects/arrays are OK.

Input object must not be mutated

const fn = memoize(obj => {
  return { sum: obj.a + obj.b, diff: obj.a - obj.b };
});

const state = { a: 1, b: 2 };
const result1 = fn(state);
state.a += 1; // Don't do this, the state object must be immutable
const result2 = fn(state); // Ends up unexpected result

The input obj or the state must be immutable. The whole concept is built around the immutability. It's faily common in Redux and React, but be careful if you are not familiar with the concept.

There's no workaround.

Input can just be one object

const fn = memoize(obj => {
  return { sum: obj.a + obj.b, diff: obj.a - obj.b };
});

The input obj is the only argument that a function can receive.

const fn = memoize((arg1, arg2) => {
  // arg2 can't be used
  // ...
});

A workaround is to create a wrapper.

const memoizeWithArgs = (fnWithArgs, options) => {
  const fn = memoize(args => fWithArgs(...args), options);
  return (...args) => fn (args);
};

Note: this will essentially bypass the tier-1 cache with WeakMap.

Comparison

Reselect

Here's a simple example in reselect.

import { createSelector } from 'reselect';

const mySelector = createSelector(
  state => state.values.value1,
  state => state.values.value2,
  (value1, value2) => value1 + value2,
);

This can be written as follows.

import memoize from 'proxy-memoize';

const mySelector = memoize(
  state => state.values.value1 + state.values.value2,
);

Another example from reselect.

const subtotalSelector = createSelector(
  state => state.shop.items,
  items => items.reduce((acc, item) => acc + item.value, 0),
);

const taxSelector = createSelector(
  subtotalSelector,
  state => state.shop.taxPercent,
  (subtotal, taxPercent) => subtotal * (taxPercent / 100),
);

export const totalSelector = createSelector(
  subtotalSelector,
  taxSelector,
  (subtotal, tax) => ({ total: subtotal + tax }),
);

This can be converted to something like this.

export const totalSelector = memoize(state => {
  const subtotal = state.shop.item.reduce((acc, item) => acc + item.value, 0);
  const tax = subtotal * (state.shop.taxPercent / 100);
  return { total: subtotal + tax };
);

Finally, see this example.

const state = {
  todos: [
    { text: 'foo', completed: false }
  ]
};
const todoTextsSelector = memoize(state => state.todos.map(todo => todo.text));

This can't be written in reselect because if the completed value is toggled, the todoTextsSelector will return a referentially new array, even though the contents is shallow equal.

jakobo/proxy-memoize