Source code for our CVPR 2022 Paper: Towards Robust and Reproducible Active Learning Using Neural Networks
Active learning (AL) is a promising ML paradigm that has the potential to parse through large unlabeled data and help reduce annotation cost in domains where labeling data can be prohibitive. Recently proposed neural network based AL methods use different heuristics to accomplish this goal. In this study, we demonstrate that under identical experimental settings, different types of AL algorithms (uncertainty based, diversity based, and committee based) produce an inconsistent gain over random sampling baseline. Through a variety of experiments, controlling for sources of stochasticity, we show that variance in performance metrics achieved by AL algorithms can lead to results that are not consistent with the previously reported results. We also found that under strong regularization, AL methods show marginal or no advantage over the random sampling baseline under a variety of experimental conditions. Finally, we conclude with a set of recommendations on how to assess the results using a new AL algorithm to ensure results are reproducible and robust under changes in experimental conditions. We share our codes to facilitate AL evaluations. We believe our findings and recommendations will help advance reproducible research in AL using neural networks.
TL;DR: An Active Learning framework built on top of pycls.
TorchAL is an evaluation toolkit with a motive to advance the reproducible research in deep active learning. We currently implement state-of-the-art active learning (AL) algorithms. Our tookit extends the widely used pycls codebase under AL settings.
- We report strong random baselines across widely used architectures and datasets.
- Our baselines are well-trained using AutoML which helps in reducing the bias introduced by choosing sub-optimal hyper-parameters.
- As we dream of reproducible results in AL, we release the training, validation index sets so that newer AL methods in future can use exact labeled set for training as we used to report our strong baselines.
- For familiarity with the codebase, we recommend interested users to go through the notebooks.
-
During AL iterations we observed that labeled set changes and therefore does the class distribution too.
-
Most prior works in AL fix the hyper-parameters at the start of AL cycle. We note that this imposes a very strong assumption i.e the hyper-parameters tuned for initial labeled partion will remain optimal for all future AL iterations.
-
Thus in contrast to contemporary AL methods which fix the training hyper-parameters at the start of AL, we tune the training hyper-parameters using AutoML.
-
To facilitate this we make use of optuna to perform random search over 50 trials for each AL cycle.
- For creating a conda environment, kindly refer to conda_env.yaml
- For installing dependencies via pip, kindly refer to requirements.txt
NOTE: In either case we have to download the dataset indexes and follow tools/train_al.py: Dataset index sets
wget https://github.com/PrateekMunjal/torchal/blob/master/dataset_indexes.zip
git clone https://github.com/PrateekMunjal/TorchAL
cd TorchAL
python setup.py install
pip install torchal
- Dataset and active set indexes: Click here to download
- Pretrained CIFAR models trained on 10% data: Click here to download
For interested readers we recommend to checkout notebook ensuring reproducible active sets. Link to Notebook
- Uncertainty
- Coreset
- BALD
- DBAL
- VAAL
- QBC
- Random Baseline
NOTE: Below 5% meains 5 percent of the full training dataset. For example, for CIFAR10 - we have 50k datapoints as their official training split so with 5% we have 2500 datapoints in our initial labeled set.
- Different budget sizes: 5%, 10%
- Different validation set sizes: 2%, 5%, 10%
- Effect of regularization techniques
- We share notebooks demonstrating such different experimental settings.
- For interested readers we recommend to follow the summary of experiments presented here.
Expand to see the full script
pythonExec=$1
cd /raid/shadab/prateek/newcode
# script params
port=5035
sampling_fn=uncertainty
lSet_partition=1
base_seed=1
num_GPU=2
al_iterations=4 #7 #4
num_aml_trials=3 #50
budget_size=5000 #2500
dataset=CIFAR10
init_partition=10
step_partition=10
clf_epochs=5 #150
num_classes=10
log_iter=40
#Data arguments
train_dir=/raid/shadab/prateek/newcode/data/$dataset/train-$dataset/
test_dir=/raid/shadab/prateek/newcode/data/$dataset/test-$dataset/
lSetPath=/raid/shadab/prateek/newcode/data/$dataset/partition_$lSet_partition/lSet_$dataset.npy
uSetPath=/raid/shadab/prateek/newcode/data/$dataset/partition_$lSet_partition/uSet_$dataset.npy
valSetPath=/raid/shadab/prateek/newcode/data/$dataset/partition_$lSet_partition/valSet_$dataset.npy
#for lSet 1
out_dir=/raid/shadab/prateek/newcode/results
# for other lSet Exps
# out_dir=/raid/shadab/prateek/newcode/results_lSetPartitions
#model_types: (i) wide_resnet_50 (ii) wide_resnet_28_10 (iii) wide_resnet_28_2
model_style=vgg_style
model_type=vgg #resnet_shake_shake
model_depth=16 #26
export CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES=0,1
$pythonExec tools/main_aml.py --n_GPU $num_GPU \
--port $port --sampling_fn $sampling_fn --lSet_partition $lSet_partition \
--seed_id $base_seed \
--init_partition $init_partition --step_partition $step_partition \
--dataset $dataset --budget_size $budget_size \
--out_dir $out_dir \
--num_aml_trials $num_aml_trials --num_classes $num_classes \
--al_max_iter $al_iterations \
--model_type $model_type --model_depth $model_depth \
--clf_epochs $clf_epochs \
--eval_period 1 --checkpoint_period 1 \
--lSetPath $lSetPath --uSetPath $uSetPath --valSetPath $valSetPath \
--train_dir $train_dir --test_dir $test_dir \
--dropout_iterations 25 \
--cfg configs/$dataset/$model_style/$model_type/R-18_4gpu_unreg.yaml \
--vaal_z_dim 32 --vaal_vae_bs 64 --vaal_epochs 15 \
--vaal_vae_lr 5e-4 --vaal_disc_lr 5e-4 --vaal_beta 1.0 --vaal_adv_param 1.0 \
Usage: Assume above script is named as **run.sh**, then we can simply run it
sh run.sh `which python`
In the above script we only need to add few more switches to add strong-regularization.
swa_lr=5e-4
swa_freq=50
swa_epochs=5 #50
...
--rand_aug --swa_mode --swa_freq $swa_freq --swa_lr $swa_lr \
--swa_epochs $swa_epochs --swa_iter 0 \
If you use TorchAL, please consider citing:
@inproceedings{Munjal2022TorchAL,
title={Towards Robust and Reproducible Active Learning Using Neural Networks},
author={Prateek Munjal and Nasir Hayat and Munawar Hayat and Jamshid Sourati
and Shadab Khan},
booktitle={CVPR},
year={2022}
}
This repository is built using the following repositories. Thanks for their wonderful works.
If you have any question about this project, please feel free to contact prateekmunjal31@gmail.com or skhan.shadab@gmail.com.