joular/joularjx

Negative consumption values reported

JeremyNison opened this issue · 4 comments

JeremyNison commented

Negative consumption values are sometimes reported in the generated .csv files. The occurences of this kind of values is variable and likly dependait of the monitored application. Particularly, executing JoularJX with the "avrora" benchmark form the DaCapo-9.12-bach benchmark suite will likely generate a bunch of negative values.

Executing the command java -javaagent:<path to joular jx jar> -jar <path to dacapo jar> avrora --size large will generate this kind of reports joularJX-11032-all-methods-energy.csv where several methods shows a negative energy consumption.

Monitoring other benchmarks of the suite, such as jython, will not generate any negative value.

adelnoureddine commented

This is usually because either the process or the Java thread is terminated before the 2nd power measurement in the loop. Hence, the negative value (0 - P1).
Hopefully in the next version, we will remove the negative values that comes from this thread/process termination issue.

adelnoureddine commented

Potential fixes available in PR #35.

adelnoureddine commented

@kifetew would you be willing to suggest your fixes to our develop branch? Feel free to submit a PR.
There has been and are going to be a few changes to the mac powermetrics measurements (see issue #54 and PR #55)

kifetew commented

sure, I'll submit a PR from my fork. I've made a number of changes to fix the negative values issue and also to make it work on Macos. My fixes need check/review on your side though to make sure that I did not misunderstand some aspects. There's also the point of watt (in mac) vs joule (in linux) that is currently implemented in joularjx to keep in mind while interpreting the results.