A take on improving the (already amazing) p5 API.
You can find examples of how to use the library here.
- Simplicity first : optimization considerations should not complexify the API, but should still be a goal if they can be transparent to the user.
- Vectors are amazing : They should be used as often as possible to abstract away the coordinate system and simplify the equations.
- Prepare for other contexts : p6 should be a great environment to get started with programming in general, and graphics programming in particular. It should introduce concepts and allow a smooth transition to other coding environments such as :
- Scripting in softwares like Blender, Illustrator or After Effects.
- Per-pixel thinking (Shadertoy like).
- Low-Level graphics programming with GPU APIs like OpenGL.
- Low-Level access : nothing should stand in the way of you writting raw OpenGL calls
- It is written in a language that doesn't allow operator overloading.
- The Vector class isn't used enough (like as a valid parameter for all the functions)
- There is no buit-in matrix type and you can't access the transform matrix.
- Ellipses are described by diameter instead of radius. If we change that we also have to change rect to take the inner radius as a parameter (a.k.a distance between center and side). Or we make overloads based on parameter name (would be nice if allowed by any language).
- rect is described by top-left corner by default, which is insconsistent with ellipse and less practical than giving a center in most cases in my opinion.
- ellipse and rect miss a rotation parameter.
- There is no proper Color type
- Colors are described with values in the range [0, 255] instead of [0, 1] by default. Hexadecimal strings are nice though.
- If you describe colors with a string, you can't add a second parameter to specify an alpha value.
- lerp is a weird and confusing name. I much prefer mix, which also has the advantage of being the one used in glsl.
- The default noise should use Simplex Noise instead of Classic Perlin Noise. Also, more noise types should be available (voronoise etc.)
- The coordinate system should be expressed in relative coordinates (-1 to 1 for y and -aspectRatio to aspectRatio for x) [Maybe we could have the option to change the state so that x becomes the axis of reference going from -1 to 1 (usefull for vertical compositions)]
- The y axis should point up, like in the classic mathematical convention, and the OpenGL one.
- Exporting an image sequence is completely broken in p5.
- There is no time() function that gives the physical time elapsed since the start of the sketch. It is the natural counterpart of framecount when we are dealing with realtime rendering. It would be nice to abstract both of these concepts behind a time() function, and adding a MODE to choose if we want realtime or fixed timestep (framecount).
- There are inconsistencies between Classic and WebGL modes (like the coordinate system).
- Circles are ugly in WebGL mode (not enough subdivisions / no adaptive subdivisions)
- p5.Graphics are not practical to use / introduce in existing code : you have to prefix every drawing call with "pg.". I would rather wrap my code in a pair of beginDraw() / endDraw() functions, just as if you were binding / unbinding another render target. Or even nicer, just one draw() function that takes in a function pointer that does the drawing code. (It would enforce wrapping your code in a scope, and would make sure you don't forget to call endDraw()).
- Javascript's modulo (%) uses the wrong convention for negative numbers (it introduces a discontinuity of behaviour between positive and negative numbers)
- Pixel arrays are 1D and are indexed as such. I think this 1D nature should be hidden to the user and we should be able to use 2D indices.
- noise() isn't defined for negative inputs
- Lacks a Custom Blend Mode option
I am strongly convinced that you should always be working in relative coordinates and that any call to window_size() is a code smell. The only use case that I can think of for window_size() is if you want to create an Image that has a size proportional to that of the window.