maccman/juggernaut

latest version fails with ie8 (socketio problems?)

inspire22 opened this issue · 9 comments

inspire22 commented

I see this in the logs:

I'm on a local network with ip-address while testing this.

It takes forever to connect. Chrome/Firefox work fine - just IE8 is having this problem.

11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 395031118998304 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "xhr-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 8955525632482022 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received: {"type":"subscribe","channel":"allpoetry_reads"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to: allpoetry_reads
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received: {"type":"subscribe","channel":"166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to: 166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:04 - Client 7418751909863204 disconnected

11 Jul 16:03:16 - Client 5521897536236793 disconnected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Client 3793639016803354 connected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"

maccman commented

Your using the npm or Github version? If not the latter - can you try it. It
has SocketIO 0.7 support.

Thanks,
Alex

On Mon, Jul 11, 2011 at 6:08 PM, inspire22 <
reply@reply.github.com>wrote:

I see this in the logs:

I'm on a local network with ip-address while testing this.

It takes forever to connect. Chrome/Firefox work fine - just IE8 is having
this problem.

11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 395031118998304 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "xhr-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 8955525632482022 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received:
{"type":"subscribe","channel":"allpoetry_reads"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to: allpoetry_reads
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received:
{"type":"subscribe","channel":"166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to: 166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:04 - Client 7418751909863204 disconnected

11 Jul 16:03:16 - Client 5521897536236793 disconnected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Client 3793639016803354 connected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#86

Alex MacCaw

+12147175129
@maccman

http://alexmaccaw.co.uk | http://www.leadthinking.com | http://socialmod.com

inspire22 commented

Yeah i was just realizing my npm upgrade hadn't gotten the latest, as the included socketio is behind still. I'll give it a shot in a minute.

inspire22 commented

How do I install the npm submodules again?

Ciao,
Kevin Watt

On Jul 11, 2011, at 4:12 PM, maccman wrote:

Your using the npm or Github version? If not the latter - can you try it. It
has SocketIO 0.7 support.

Thanks,
Alex

On Mon, Jul 11, 2011 at 6:08 PM, inspire22 <
reply@reply.github.com>wrote:

I see this in the logs:

I'm on a local network with ip-address while testing this.

It takes forever to connect. Chrome/Firefox work fine - just IE8 is having
this problem.

11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 395031118998304 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "xhr-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 8955525632482022 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received:
{"type":"subscribe","channel":"allpoetry_reads"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to: allpoetry_reads
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received:
{"type":"subscribe","channel":"166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to: 166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:04 - Client 7418751909863204 disconnected

11 Jul 16:03:16 - Client 5521897536236793 disconnected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Client 3793639016803354 connected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#86

Alex MacCaw

+12147175129
@maccman

http://alexmaccaw.co.uk | http://www.leadthinking.com | http://socialmod.com

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#86 (comment)

maccman commented

Npm dependencies?

git clone git://github.com/maccman/juggernaut.git
cd juggernaut
npm install .

On Mon, Jul 11, 2011 at 6:38 PM, inspire22 <
reply@reply.github.com>wrote:

How do I install the npm submodules again?

Ciao,
Kevin Watt

On Jul 11, 2011, at 4:12 PM, maccman wrote:

Your using the npm or Github version? If not the latter - can you try it.
It
has SocketIO 0.7 support.

Thanks,
Alex

On Mon, Jul 11, 2011 at 6:08 PM, inspire22 <
reply@reply.github.com>wrote:

I see this in the logs:

I'm on a local network with ip-address while testing this.

It takes forever to connect. Chrome/Firefox work fine - just IE8 is
having
this problem.

11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 395031118998304 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Initializing client with transport "xhr-polling"
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client 8955525632482022 connected
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received:
{"type":"subscribe","channel":"allpoetry_reads"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to: allpoetry_reads
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Received:
{"type":"subscribe","channel":"166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6"}
11 Jul 16:02:56 - Client subscribing to:
166a9c1adac3dc8f51d8ce3d22a5d7a6
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:02:57 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:04 - Client 7418751909863204 disconnected

11 Jul 16:03:16 - Client 5521897536236793 disconnected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Initializing client with transport "jsonp-polling"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Client 3793639016803354 connected
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:46 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"
11 Jul 16:03:49 - Couldnt find client with session id "6642279957886785"

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#86

Alex MacCaw

+12147175129
@maccman

http://alexmaccaw.co.uk | http://www.leadthinking.com |
http://socialmod.com

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#86 (comment)

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#86 (comment)

Alex MacCaw

+12147175129
@maccman

http://alexmaccaw.co.uk | http://www.leadthinking.com | http://socialmod.com

inspire22 commented

Seems to be working really well.

I've still never seen firefox or IE connect with flash sockets, but xhr-polling seems to be working fine for them. I'm setting window.WEB_SOCKET_SWF_LOCATION = "/images/WebSocketMain.swf" in my document head before I load juggernaut's application.js.

--silent still doesn't disable log output

Thanks!

inspire22 commented

also jug.state doesn't seem to be set anymore, but I can approximate it I think with jug.io.socket.connected & connecting

maccman commented

Don't set WEB_SOCKET_SWF_LOCATION - you don't need to anymore.

Yup, --silent needs to be implemented.

Yes, jug.state isn't needed either - event handlers should do all you need.

On Mon, Jul 11, 2011 at 7:03 PM, inspire22 <
reply@reply.github.com>wrote:

Seems to be working really well.

I've still never seen firefox or IE connect with flash sockets, but
xhr-polling seems to be working fine for them. I'm setting
window.WEB_SOCKET_SWF_LOCATION = "/images/WebSocketMain.swf" in my document
head before I load juggernaut's application.js.

--silent still doesn't disable log output

Thanks!

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#86 (comment)

Alex MacCaw

+12147175129
@maccman

http://alexmaccaw.co.uk | http://www.leadthinking.com | http://socialmod.com

inspire22 commented

It was working great with websocket @ chrome, but sometimes that falls through still (websocket sucks?) Then I get these errors:

It seems to send 'Welcome to socket.io.' @ each connection - seems like a waste of bandwidth, and gives this error:
Resource interpreted as Script but transferred with MIME type text/plain.
0:1Uncaught SyntaxError: Unexpected identifier

Then it fails & doesn't try anything else (like jsonP polling). Looks like jug.socket.options has "reconnect: false" - maybe thats why it doesn't try the next transport method?

I've also gotten this a few times @ chrome
XMLHttpRequest cannot load http://site.com:8080/socket.io/xhr-polling//1310517530166. Origin http://site.com is not allowed by Access-Control-Allow-Origin.

XHR-polling is working fine on firefox despite the port difference

avitus commented

I'm using Juggernaut 2 (2.0.3 I think) with Node 0.49, socket.io 0.73.

It appears that websockets is working on Chrome 12. It's a bit difficult to tell ... I see a lot of websocket upgrade handshakes and 101's (always of type 'pending') but I don't see any 'socket_io/1/xhr-polling' type requests.

Firefox 6 seems to be all XHR-polling in Firebug. Same on IE9.

Am I doing something wrong or is that the current state of affairs?