mate-desktop/mate-control-center

Time cannot be set manually in mate-time-admin if ntp sync is unavailable (or disabled)

mesov opened this issue · 6 comments

mesov commented

Expected behaviour

If no ntp sync daemon is installed, or if ntp sync is disabled, system time can be set manually by clicking on the "+" and "-" buttons and date can be set manually by clicking on the calendar.

Actual behaviour

If no ntp sync daemon is installed, or if ntp sync is disabled, the "Time" and "Date" fields are greyed, and the buttons to set time are disabled.

  • if no ntp sync daemon is detected, switching the NTP sync button back and forth has not effect, time and date cannot be set manually through the Time and Date Manager UI,

  • if a sync daemon is installed but disabled, switching it on and off makes it possible to use the "+" and "-" buttons to set time manually, or to click on the calendar to change the date, until the Time and Date Manager is closed. After it has been closed and opened again, ntp sync needs to be switched on and off again in order to be able to set time/date manually.

Steps to reproduce the behaviour

Start Time and Date Manager. If no time sync daemon is available, notice that the "Time" and "Date" fields are greyed. If a time sync daemon is installed and enabled, switch it off, close the Time and Date Manager UI, open it again, and notice that the "Time" and "Date" fields are greyed.

MATE general version

MATE 1.26

Package version

mate-control-center 1.26.1.1

Linux Distribution

Ubuntu MATE 23.10 Mantic

Link to bugreport of your Distribution (requirement)

https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu-mate/+bug/2061691

mesov commented

systemd-timesyncd is the ntp sync daemon installed on this system. It is enabled by default, and works fine.

mesov commented

Note that the time zone can be changed by clicking on the "Edit" button:

mate-time-admin

zhuyaliang commented

Thank you for your report

Ark74 commented

Moving comment to the issue itself:
Hello and thank you for taking a look into the issue #750

I'm testing this change on mate-control-center-1.26.0-2ubuntu3 (jammy) on Trisquel which comes without systemd-timesyncd enabled by default and I see no actual change from the original behaviour.

ubuntu noble ships 1.26.1-1.1build3, I'll try setup an environment that would match the one reported and see if something changes.

Regards.

Ark74 commented

I did test on Noble,

Steps to test

  • Install Ubuntu Mate - Noble (24.04)
  • Remove systemd-timesync
  • Reboot
  • Not possible to set time.

0 initial_cmd_ouput

Apply fix commit

  • Get source apt source mate-control-center
  • apply patch 8fd4dd2, update version at changelog
  • then rebuild (dpkg-buildpackage) and update binaries.
  • Result: clean output in terminal, still not possible to modify the time.

3 patched-time-admin

End of testing.

zhuyaliang commented

Thank you for your testing. I will continue to modify and update the code

  • 👍1