/zfs-boottime-encryption

Unlocking ZFS datasets at boot

Boot-time unlocking of ZFS encrypted datasets

Note
 A disclaimer about the status of this document, as of January 2020: With ZoL version 0.8.1 and newer, systemd mount generators exist that can automatically take a passphase at boot time and largely obsolete this guide. If you don’t want the datasets protected by a passphrase you can type, this document may still serve you well, though the weakness still lies with the strength of the “keystore” passphrase.

Background and motivation

As of ZFS-on-Linux 0.8.0, native encryption is available and it can be a desirable feature. On a basic level, it secures data in the case of computer or disk-drive theft, it ensures that your data won’t be recovered if the disk as a whole fails and you can’t erase it manually anymore. It will not protect against any kind of attacks while the system is running. Malware and such will be able to read any available encrypted dataset freely. This is in common with all other disk encryption methods: it protects data at-rest, not in-use (where zfs get keystatus is available).

For the full technical details, see Tom Caputi’s talk on ZFS native encryption. The command set is different from the video (much earlier in its development), but it largely still holds.

With all this in mind, I decided to move my home datasets over to being encrypted. Trusting ZFS’s (current) default with encryption=on (which is the same as aes-256-ccm)[1], I moved my entire $HOME dataset tree. Non-raw zfs sends actually make it pretty easy to convert between encrypted and unencrypted, and that step is easy…

Just the one thing: How will I unlock the datasets at boot time, mostly automatically, in a safe manner?

There are three possibilities for this:

  1. A PAM module, with the dataset’s properties as keyformat=passphrase and keylocation=prompt. This might be nice, but no such PAM module exists and I don’t have much interest in writing it.

  2. With keyformat=passphrase and keylocation=prompt, a special boot service that prompts for the passphrase. This already exists for cryptsetup, the implementation of which seems to be built into systemd and possibly could be adapted for zfs load-key. I made attempts to write one using systemd-ask-passphrase, but was unsuccessful, which leads to the last and actual implementation I ended up on…

  3. keyformat=raw and keylocation=file://$PATH, ZFS can automatically load the key from a 32-byte file of random data. This needs to be preloaded and requires a secure location for this file itself (if the key is available unencrypted, all the time, your data may as well be unencrypted too). On the plus side, as I mentioned in the last point, cryptsetup already has perfectly good support for boot-time unlocking and may be used to assist with this problem.

The solution I use for myself is the third one. The key file might be stored on a USB drive for temporary access when required, but I don’t have a desire to dedicate a USB drive for such a purpose. I’d much rather have the system be pretty self-suficient, which means I’ll need a zvol encrypted with LUKS (not ZFS’s encryption), which gets unlocked with a passphrase, mounted, and zfs load-key works.

Step 1: Make the zvol

LUKS actually has a surprisingly large header, I found, when my first attempt to make a 10M zvol failed as soon as I tried to luksFormat it. A larger zvol should not be a very big deal (I have a 4TB pool in my desktop), and I opted to create a 50M volume, then format it with cryptsetup. For good measure, I fill up all the available space first, then do a mkfs:

# zfs create -V 50m rpool/keystore
# cryptsetup luksFormat /dev/zvol/rpool/keystore
(type YES and your passphrase)
# cryptsetup open --type luks /dev/zvol/rpool/keystore keystore
# cp /dev/zero /dev/mapper/keystore
# mkfs.fat /dev/mapper/keystore

I choose FAT because it is a very simple file system, and with the right mount options, you never need to worry about a program accidentally creating insecure permissions. This part can easily be adjusted to have an ext2 formatted volume or anything, if desired.

Add the LUKS volume to /etc/crypttab, which should trigger systemd at boot time to prompt for the passphrase:

# echo 'keystore /dev/zvol/rpool/keystore none' >> /etc/crypttab

The third field is “password” and the value of “none” causes systemd to prompt for the password interactively. This was not intuitive to me, but it is what it is.

Add the volume to /etc/fstab and mount it. Just for my own peace of mind, I keep it mounted read-only by default so no possibility of writes or corruption happens, so the mount command needs an extra option.

# mkdir /etc/keystore
# echo '/dev/mapper/keystore /etc/keystore vfat dmask=077,fmask=177,ro 0 2' >> /etc/fstab
# mount -o rw /etc/keystore

Step 2: Generate keys

This is pretty straight-forward, ZFS only needs files 32 bytes of length of random data for its key (when keyformat=raw). This may be accomplished as simply as this:

# dd if=/dev/urandom of=/etc/keystore/home-user.key bs=32 count=1

The file name is arbitrary and may be whatever you like. I generally like the form of ${DATASET}.key.

If you have locate(1) on your system, updatedb(8) can leak the entire directory tree of your datasets. I feel this is undesirable, and I opt to make an encrypted dataset for its database so that it may still operate fully normally, but my file names are still safe from prying eyes. An alternative is to exclude paths in /etc/updatedb.conf, but then the usefulness of the tool is gone for me.

# dd if=/dev/urandom of=/etc/keystore/var-lib-mlocate.key bs=32 count=1

Add as many files as needed. There is no technical requirement that each encryptionroot needs to have a unique key, but it is a very good idea nonetheless.

Step 3: Set appropriate dataset properties

This could be done at zfs create time, or zfs receive, if planning ahead, but I didn’t. Luckily, the actual key ZFS uses to encrypt datasets is not really user-visible and the file and/or passphrase is merely a way to unlock this hidden key. This makes it pretty easy to modify the values after the fact, to change passphrase or file. (LUKS actually works in the exact same way.)

I’ll still document all the methods:

From scratch:

# zfs create -o encryption=aes-256-gcm -o keyformat=raw -o keylocation=file:///etc/keystore/home-user.key rpool/home/user

From a send stream (non-raw only, read the manpage!), adjust redirect or pipe accordingly:

# zfs receive -o encryption=aes-256-gcm -o keyformat=raw -o keylocation=file:///etc/keystore/home-user.key rpool/home/user < /some/place/zfs-sendstream

After the fact, if you created it first with a passphrase and change to this method:

# zfs change-key -o keyformat=raw -o keylocation=file:///etc/keystore/home-user.key rpool/home/user

I also created a rpool/var/lib/mlocate dataset to protect against the file tree from being leaked. This location might have to be adjusted per locate(1) implementation.

Step 4: systemd service to run zfs load-key

After all of this, we are almost done. Just need one more piece of the puzzle, so that zfs can load the keys for datasets and automatically mount them afterward.

# cat > /etc/systemd/system/zfs-load-key.service <<EOF
[Unit]
Description=Load encryption keys
DefaultDependencies=false
Before=zfs-mount.service
After=zfs-import.target

[Service]
Type=oneshot
RemainAfterExit=yes
ExecStart=/usr/bin/zfs load-key -a

[Install]
WantedBy=zfs-mount.service
EOF
# systemctl enable zfs-load-key.service

This file can be adjusted as needed. zfs load-key -a automatically tries to load the keys for all encrypted datasets, which works for my case (all keys are in /etc/keystore).

Multiple ExecStart lines can be used, systemd starts them up one after another. To be more selective, you could replace the line with something like:

ExecStart=/usr/bin/zfs load-key rpool/home/user
ExecStart=/usr/bin/zfs load-key rpool/var/lib/mlocate

This could be useful if you have other datasets you want to more manually manage.

Step 5: Profit!

At this point, everything should be in place. Upon rebooting, systemd will halt the boot to ask for the keystore passphrase, which resides on a LUKS-encrypted zvol. It will mount the unlocked keystore at /etc/keystore and continue the boot process. zfs-load-key.service is specified to be run before zfs-mount.service, to load all the encryption keys, and finally the system continues booting per normal, with all datasets available to mount.

1. A default encryption value of aes-256-ccm holds true up to 0.8.3, but the default in a future release (whether 0.8.4 or 2.0) is changing to aes-256-gcm. It is recommended to use that now, and to convert ccm datasets to gcm if you have the time.