mpjashby/crimemapping

Add cartography package to area mapping tutorial

Closed this issue · 1 comments

The tutorial 'Mapping area data' currently uses the tmap package for static choropleth maps. These would be better done with the cartography package because it allows inclusion of base maps on static choropleth maps. Keep using tmap as a wrapper around leaflet for dynamic maps.

The cartography package has been discontinued since the issue was raised and the replacement mapsf package does not currently include functions for getting map tiles, so it has no real advantages over using ggmap. It would be possible to transition the tutorial to use cartography for now and then mapsf if/when it supports getting map tiles, but the benefits of doing so do not justify re-writing the tutorial twice.

The problem of misaligned map tiles in small-scale ggmap maps (dkahle/ggmap#298) still exists, but there doesn't appear to be a solution to it at present (not least because ggmap now appears orphaned) so I'm closing this issue.