/ruby_framework_bench

ruby framework bench with goliath, grape and sinatra, incude multi-thread and fiber running mode.

Primary LanguageRuby

conclusion

  1. Fiber比Multi-thread可以节省很多CPU调度开销，running状态的thread/fiber越多，Fiber的性能优势越明显
  2. Multi-thread如果并发线程不是很高的情况下，性能也不错，和Fiber的差距不明显，而且驱动，库和代码兼容性相比Fiber更容易处理
  3. 在这个简单测试当中，Sinatra和Grape同样跑多线程，性能差异非常小

recommendation

  1. 对IO并发不是非常高的场景下，推荐用多线程跑sinatra/grape，性能相当好
  2. 对IO并发要求很高的场景下，推荐用fier跑sinatra/grape，相比多线程，CPU消耗有明显下降
  3. Sinatra和Grape没有太大性能差异，Sinatra内置模版功能，Grape的API功能很强大，如果需要用到模版渲染，建议使用Sinatra；如果是纯json/xml API，推荐Grape
  4. 多线程服务器，推荐使用Rainbows
  5. 用Grape跑Fiber，推荐Goliath；用Sinatra跑Fiber，推荐Thin
  6. Sinatra Fiber运行在Thin上面，似乎比 Grape on Goliath性能略好一点

一些测试数据没有更新和补充，建议看上面的结论。或者自行测试。

siege -c30 -r100 http://localhost:9000/v1/posts/1

Grape on Goliath

CPU: 12-14%(MacBookPro) 9%(iMac)
Memory: 70MB
Throughput: 64.84 60.54 58.53

Grape on Rainbows

CPU: 12-14%(MacBookPro) 11%(iMac)
Memory: 75MB
Throughput: 64.84 60.54 58.53

Sinatra on Rainbows

CPU: 11-12%(iMac)
Memory: 67MB
Throughput: 58.46 60.51 57.40

Sinatra on Thin

CPU: 9-11%(iMac)
Memory: 64MB
Throughput: 62.44 57.52 63.50

siege -c50 -r100 http://localhost:9000/v1/posts/1

Grape on Goliath

CPU: 15%(iMac)
Memory: 70MB
Throughput: 63.78 60.83 60.70

Grape on Rainbows

CPU: 18%(iMac)
Memory: 75MB
Throughput: 64.84 60.54 58.53

Sinatra on Rainbows

CPU: 18-20%(iMac)
Memory: 70MB
Throughput: 61.56 60.43 60.41

Sinatra on Thin

CPU: 13-15%(iMac)
Memory: 66MB
Throughput: 62.78 62.69 60.47

siege -c100 -r100 http://localhost:9000/v1/posts/1

Grape on Goliath

CPU: 33-37%(MacBookPro) 30%(iMac)
Memory: 70MB
Throughput: 62.09 63.87 62.08

Grape on Rainbows

CPU: 38%(iMac)
Memory: 75MB
Throughput: 62.09 63.87 62.08

Sinatra on Rainbows

CPU: 38%(iMac)
Memory: 72MB
Throughput: 62.85 65.91 59.92

Sinatra on Thin

CPU: 27-30%(iMac)
Memory: 67MB
Throughput: 60.84 61.85 62.84

siege -c200 -r100 http://localhost:9000/v1/posts/1

Grape on Goliath

CPU: 60-70%(MacBookPro) 55-60%(iMac)
Memory: 70MB
Throughput: 65.62 67.12 68.67

Grape on Rainbows

CPU: 75-79%(iMac)
Memory: 77MB
Throughput: 65.62 67.12 68.67

Sinatra on Rainbows

CPU: 75-81%(iMac)
Memory: 73MB
Throughput: 61.80 66.50 65.74

Sinatra on Thin

CPU: 53-57%(iMac)
Memory: 70MB
Throughput: 68.92 62.83 65.08

wait 0.5s in database.

Sinatra on Thin

c30 61MB 5-6% 55s
c50 63MB 8-10% 58s
c100 65MB 16-18% 58s
c200 69MB 32-34% 61s

Goliath Fiber Spawn

c30 63MB 5-6% 57s
c50 64MB 9-10% 57s
c100 67MB 18-20% 58s
c200 77MB 35-40% 58s

Rainbows Thread Spawn

c30 61MB 5-7% 55s
c50 62MB 9-11% 56s
c100 63MB 20-22% 58s
c200 67MB 44-47% 62s

Rainbows Thread Pool Grape

c30 67MB 5-8% 56s
c50 69MB 9-12% 58s
c100 71MB 20-22% 59s
c200 72MB 44-45% 59.83s

Rainbows Thread Pool Sinatra

c30 72MB 5-7% 56s
c50 73MB 9-11% 58s
c100 74MB 19-21% 58s
c200 74MB 40-45% 58s