🎉 Ultra-simplified explanation to design patterns! 🎉
A topic that can easily make anyone's mind wobble. Here I try to make them stick in to your mind (and maybe mine) by explaining them in the simplest way possible.
***Design patterns are solutions to recurring problems; guidelines on how to tackle certain problems. They are not classes, packages or libraries that you can plug into your application and wait for the magic to happen. These are, rather, guidelines on how to tackle certain problems in certain situations.
Design patterns solutions to recurring problems; guidelines on how to tackle certain problems
Wikipedia describes them as
In software engineering, a software design pattern is a general reusable solution to a commonly occurring problem within a given context in software design. It is not a finished design that can be transformed directly into source or machine code. It is a description or template for how to solve a problem that can be used in many different situations.
- Design patterns are not a silver bullet to all your problems.
- Do not try to force them; bad things are supposed to happen, if done so. Keep in mind that design patterns are solutions to problems, not solutions finding problems; so don't overthink.
- If used in a correct place in a correct manner, they can prove to be a savior; or else they can result in a horrible mess of a code.
In plain words
Creational patterns are focused towards how to instantiate an object or group of related objects.
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, creational design patterns are design patterns that deal with object creation mechanisms, trying to create objects in a manner suitable to the situation. The basic form of object creation could result in design problems or added complexity to the design. Creational design patterns solve this problem by somehow controlling this object creation.
Real world example
Consider, you are building a house and you need doors. It would be a mess if every time you need a door, you put on your carpenter clothes and start making a door in your house. Instead you get it made from a factory.
In plain words
Simple factory simply generates an instance for client without exposing any instantiation logic to the client
Wikipedia says
In object-oriented programming (OOP), a factory is an object for creating other objects – formally a factory is a function or method that returns objects of a varying prototype or class from some method call, which is assumed to be "new".
Programmatic Example
First of all we have a door interface and the implementation
interface Door {
public function getWidth() : float;
public function getHeight() : float;
}
class WoodenDoor implements Door {
protected $width;
protected $height;
public function __construct(float $width, float $height) {
$this->width = $width;
$this->height = $height;
}
public function getWidth() : float {
return $this->width;
}
public function getHeight() : float {
return $this->height;
}
}Then we have our door factory that makes the door and returns it
class DoorFactory {
public static function makeDoor($width, $height) : Door {
return new WoodenDoor($width, $height);
}
}And then it can be used as
$door = DoorFactory::makeDoor(100, 200);
echo 'Width: ' . $door->getWidth();
echo 'Height: ' . $door->getHeight();When to Use?
When creating an object is not just a few assignments and involves some logic, it makes sense to put it in a dedicated factory instead of repeating the same code everywhere.
Real world example
Consider the case of a hiring manager. It is impossible for one person to interview for each of the positions. Based on the job opening, she has to decide and delegate the interview steps to different people.
In plain words
It provides a way to delegate the instantiation logic to child classes.
Wikipedia says
In class-based programming, the factory method pattern is a creational pattern that uses factory methods to deal with the problem of creating objects without having to specify the exact class of the object that will be created. This is done by creating objects by calling a factory method—either specified in an interface and implemented by child classes, or implemented in a base class and optionally overridden by derived classes—rather than by calling a constructor.
Programmatic Example
Taking our hiring manager example above. First of all we have an interviewer interface and some implementations for it
interface Interviewer {
public function askQuestions();
}
class Developer implements Interviewer {
public function askQuestions() {
echo 'Asking about design patterns!';
}
}
class CommunityExecutive implements Interviewer {
public function askQuestions() {
echo 'Asking about community building';
}
}Now let us create our HiringManager
class HiringManager {
// Factory method
abstract public function makeInterviewer() : Interviewer;
public function takeInterview() {
$interviewer = $this->makeInterviewer();
$interviewer->askQuestions();
}
}Now any child can extend it and provide the required interviewer
class DevelopmentManager extends HiringManager {
public function makeInterviewer() : Interviewer {
return new Developer();
}
}
class MarketingManager extends HiringManager {
public function makeInterviewer() : Interviewer {
return new CommunityExecutive();
}
}and then it can be used as
$devManager = new DevelopmentManager();
$devManager->takeInterview(); // Output: Asking about design patterns
$marketingManager = new MarketingManager();
$marketingManager->takeInterview(); // Output: Asking about community building.When to use?
Useful when there is some generic processing in a class but the required sub-class is dynamically decided at runtime. Or putting it in other words, when the client doesn't know what exact sub-class it might need.
Real world example
Extending our door example from Simple Factory. Based on your needs you might get a wooden door from a wooden door shop, iron door from an iron shop or a PVC door from the relevant shop. Plus you might need a guy with different kind of specialities to fit the door, for example a carpenter for wooden door, welder for iron door etc. As you can see there is a dependency between the doors now, wooden door needs carpenter, iron door needs a welder etc.
In plain words
A factory of factories; a factory that groups the individual but related/dependent factories together without specifying their concrete classes.
Wikipedia says
The abstract factory pattern provides a way to encapsulate a group of individual factories that have a common theme without specifying their concrete classes
Programmatic Example
Translating the door example above. First of all we have our Door interface and some implementation for it
interface Door {
public function getDescription();
}
class WoodenDoor implements Door {
public function getDescription() {
echo 'I am a wooden door';
}
}
class IronDoor implements Door {
public function getDescription() {
echo 'I am an iron door';
}
}Then we have some fitting experts for each door type
interface DoorFittingExpert {
public function getDescription();
}
class Welder implements DoorFittingExpert {
public function getDescription() {
echo 'I can only fit iron doors';
}
}
class Carpenter implements DoorFittingExpert {
public function getDescription() {
echo 'I can only fit wooden doors';
}
}Now we have our abstract factory that would let us make family of related objects i.e. wooden door would create a wooden door fitting expert and iron door would create an iron door fitting expert
interface DoorFactory {
public function makeDoor() : Door;
public function makeFittingExpert() : DoorFittingExpert;
}
// Wooden factory to return carpenter and wooden door
class WoodenDoorFactory implements DoorFactory {
public function makeDoor() : Door {
return new WoodenDoor();
}
public function makeFittingExpert() : DoorFittingExpert{
return new Carpenter();
}
}
// Iron door factory to get iron door and the relevant fitting expert
class IronDoorFactory implements DoorFactory {
public function makeDoor() : Door {
return new IronDoor();
}
public function makeFittingExpert() : DoorFittingExpert{
return new Welder();
}
}And then it can be used as
$woodenFactory = new WoodenDoorFactory();
$door = $woodenFactory->makeDoor();
$expert = $woodenFactory->makeFittingExpert();
$door->getDescription(); // Output: I am a wooden door
$expert->getDescription(); // Output: I can only fit wooden doors
// Same for Iron Factory
$ironFactory = new IronDoorFactory();
$door = $ironFactory->makeDoor();
$expert = $ironFactory->makeFittingExpert();
$door->getDescription(); // Output: I am an iron door
$expert->getDescription(); // Output: I can only fit iron doorsAs you can see the wooden door factory has encapsulated the carpenter and the wooden door also iron door factory has encapsulated the iron door and welder. And thus it had helped us make sure that for each of the created door, we do not get a wrong fitting expert.
When to use?
When there are interrelated dependencies with not-that-simple creation logic involved
Real world example
Imagine you are at Hardee's and you order a specific deal, lets say, "Big Hardee" and they hand it over to you without any questions; this is the example of simple factory. But there are cases when the creation logic might involve more steps. For example you want a customized Subway deal, you have several options in how your burger is made e.g what bread do you want? what types of sauces would you like? What cheese would you want? etc. In such cases builder pattern comes to the rescue.
In plain words
Allows you to create different flavors of an object while avoiding constructor pollution. Useful when there could be several flavors of an object. Or when there are a lot of steps involved in creation of an object.
Wikipedia says
The builder pattern is an object creation software design pattern with the intentions of finding a solution to the telescoping constructor anti-pattern.
Having said that let me add a bit about what telescoping constructor anti-pattern is. At one point or the other we have all seen a constructor like below:
public function __construct($size, $cheese = true, $pepperoni = true, $tomato = false, $lettuce = true) {
}As you can see; the number of constructor parameters can quickly get out of hand and it might become difficult to understand the arrangement of parameters. Plus this parameter list could keep on growing if you would want to add more options in future. This is called telescoping constructor anti-pattern.
Programmatic Example
The sane alternative is to use the builder pattern.
class BurgerBuilder {
protected $size;
protected $pepperoni = true;
protected $cheeze = true;
protected $lettuce = true;
protected $tomato = false;
public function __construct(int $size) {
$this->size = $size;
}
public function addPepperoni() {
$this->pepperoni = true;
return $this;
}
public function addLettuce() {
$this->lettuce = true;
return $this;
}
public function addTomato() {
$this->tomato = true;
return $this;
}
public function build() : Burger {
// creational logic
return $burger;
}
}And then it can be used as:
$burger = (new BurgerBuilder(14))
->addPepperoni();
->addLettuce();
->addTomato();
->build();When to use?
When there could be several flavors of an object and to avoid the constructor telescoping. The key difference from the factory pattern is that; factory pattern is to be used when the creation is a one step process while builder pattern is to be used when the creation is a multi step process.
Real world example
Remember dolly? The sheep that was cloned! Lets not get into the details but the key point here is that it is all about cloning
In plain words
Create object based on an existing object through cloning.
Wikipedia says
The prototype pattern is a creational design pattern in software development. It is used when the type of objects to create is determined by a prototypical instance, which is cloned to produce new objects.
In short, it allows you to create a copy of an existing object and modify it to your needs, instead of going through the trouble of creating an object from scratch and setting it up.
Programmatic Example
In PHP, it can be easily done using clone
class Sheep {
protected $name;
protected $category;
public function __construct(string $name, string $category = 'Mountain Sheep') {
$this->name = $name;
$this->category = $category;
}
public function setName(string $name) {
$this->name = $name;
}
public function getName() {
return $this->name;
}
public function setCategory(string $category) {
$this->category = $category;
}
public function getCategory() {
return $this->category;
}
}Then it can be cloned like below
$original = new Sheep('Jolly');
echo $original->getName(); // Jolly
echo $original->getCategory(); // Mountain Sheep
// Clone and modify what is required
$cloned = clone $original;
$cloned->setName('Dolly');
echo $cloned->getName(); // Dolly
echo $cloned->getCategory(); // Mountain sheepAlso you could use the magic method __clone to modify the cloning behavior.
When to use?
When an object is required that is similar to existing object or when the creation would be expensive as compared to cloning.
Real world example
There can only be one president of a country at a time. The same president has to be brought to action, whenever duty calls. President here is singleton.
In plain words
Ensures that only one object of a particular class is every created.
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, the singleton pattern is a software design pattern that restricts the instantiation of a class to one object. This is useful when exactly one object is needed to coordinate actions across the system.
Singleton pattern is actually considered an anti-pattern and overuse of it should be avoided. It is not necessarily bad and could have some valid use-cases but should be used with caution because it introduces a global state in your application and change to it in one place could affect in the other areas and it could become pretty difficult to debug. The other bad thing about them is it makes your code tightly coupled plus it mocking the singleton could be difficult.
Programmatic Example
To create a singleton, make the constructor private, disable cloning, disable extension and create a static variable to house the instance
final class President {
private static $instance;
private function __construct() {
// Hide the constructor
}
public static function getInstance() : President {
if ($this->instance) {
return $this->instance;
}
$this->instance = new President();
return $this->instance;
}
private function __clone() {
// Disable cloning
}
}Then in order to use
$president1 = President::getInstance();
$president2 = President::getInstance();
var_dump($president1 === $president2); // trueIn plain words
Structural patterns are mostly concerned with object composition or in other words how the entities can use each other. Or yet another explanation would be, they help in answering "How to build a software component?"
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, structural design patterns are design patterns that ease the design by identifying a simple way to realize relationships between entities.
Real world example
Consider that you have some pictures in your memory card and you need to transfer them to your computer. In order to transfer them you need some kind of adapter that is compatible with your computer ports so that you can attach memory card to your computer. In this case card reader is an adapter. Another example would be the famous power adapter; a three legged plug can't be connected to a two pronged outlet, it needs to use a power adapter that makes it compatible with the two pronged outlet. Yet another example would be a translator translating words spoken by one person to another
In plain words
Adapter pattern lets you wrap an otherwise incompatible object in an adapter to make it compatible with another class.
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, the adapter pattern is a software design pattern that allows the interface of an existing class to be used as another interface. It is often used to make existing classes work with others without modifying their source code.
Programmatic Example
Consider a game where there is a hunter and he hunts lions.
First we have an interface Lion that all types of lions have to implement
interface Lion {
public function roar();
}
class AfricanLion implements Lion {
public function roar() {}
}
class AsianLion implements Lion {
public function roar() {}
}And hunter expects any implementation of Lion interface to hunt.
class Hunter {
public function hunt(Lion $lion) {
}
}Now let's say we have to add a WildDog in our game so that hunter can hunt that also. But we can't do that directly because dog has a different interface. To make it compatible for our hunter, we will have to create an adapter that is compatible
// This needs to be added to the game
class WildDog {
public function bark() {}
}
// Adapter around wild dog to make it compatible with our game
class WildDogAdapter implements Lion {
protected $dog;
public function __construct(WildDog $dog) {
$this->dog = $dog;
}
public function roar() {
$this->dog->bark();
}
}And now the WildDog can be used in our game using WildDogAdapter.
$wildDog = new WildDog();
$wildDogAdapter = new WildDogAdapter($wildDog);
$hunter = new Hunter();
$hunter->hunt($wildDogAdapter);Real world example
Consider you have a website with different pages and you are supposed to allow the user to change the theme. What would you do? Create multiple copies of each of the pages for each of the themes or would you just create separate theme and load them based on the user's preferences? Bridge pattern allows you to do the second i.e.
In Plain Words
Bridge pattern is about preferring composition over inheritance. Implementation details are pushed from a hierarchy to another object with a separate hierarchy.
Wikipedia says
The bridge pattern is a design pattern used in software engineering that is meant to "decouple an abstraction from its implementation so that the two can vary independently"
Programmatic Example
Translating our WebPage example from above. Here we have the WebPage hierarchy
interface WebPage {
public function __construct(Theme $theme);
public function getContent();
}
class About implements WebPage {
protected $theme;
public function __construct(Theme $theme) {
$this->theme = $theme;
}
public function getContent() {
return "About page in " . $this->theme->getColor();
}
}
class Careers implements WebPage {
protected $theme;
public function __construct(Theme $theme) {
$this->theme = $theme;
}
public function getContent() {
return "Careers page in " . $this->theme->getColor();
}
}And the separate theme hierarchy
interface Theme {
public function getColor();
}
class DarkTheme implements Theme {
public function getColor() {
return 'Dark Black';
}
}
class LightTheme implements Theme {
public function getColor() {
return 'Off white';
}
}
class AquaTheme implements Theme {
public function getColor() {
return 'Light blue';
}
}And both the hierarchies
$darkTheme = new DarkTheme();
$about = new About($darkTheme);
$careers = new Careers($darkTheme);
echo $about->getContent(); // "About page in Dark Black";
echo $careers->getContent(); // "Careers page in Dark Black";Real world example
Every organization is composed of employees. Each of the employees has same features i.e. has a salary, has some responsibilities, may or may not report to someone, may or may not have some subordinates etc.
In plain words
Composite pattern lets clients to treat the individual objects in a uniform manner.
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, the composite pattern is a partitioning design pattern. The composite pattern describes that a group of objects is to be treated in the same way as a single instance of an object. The intent of a composite is to "compose" objects into tree structures to represent part-whole hierarchies. Implementing the composite pattern lets clients treat individual objects and compositions uniformly.
Programmatic Example
Taking our employees example from above. Here we have different employee types
interface Employee {
public function __construct(string $name, float $salary);
public function getName() : string;
public function setSalary(float $salary);
public function getSalary() : float;
public function getRoles() : array;
}
class Developer implements Employee {
protected $salary;
protected $name;
public function __construct(string $name, float $salary) {
$this->name = $name;
$this->salary = $salary;
}
public function getName() : string {
return $this->name;
}
public function setSalary(float $salary) {
$this->salary = $salary;
}
public function getSalary() : float {
return $this->salary;
}
public function getRoles() : array {
reutrn $this->roles
}
}
class Designer implements Employee {
protected $salary;
protected $name;
public function __construct(string $name, float $salary) {
$this->name = $name;
$this->salary = $salary;
}
public function getName() : string {
return $this->name;
}
public function setSalary(float $salary) {
$this->salary = $salary;
}
public function getSalary() : float {
return $this->salary;
}
public function getRoles() : array {
reutrn $this->roles
}
}Then we have an organization which consists of several different types of employees
class Organization {
protected $employees;
public function addEmployee(Employee $employee) {
$this->employees[] = $employee;
}
public function getNetSalaries() : float {
$netSalary = 0;
foreach ($this->employees as $employee) {
$netSalary += $employee->getSalary();
}
return $netSalary;
}
}And then it can be used as
// Prepare the employees
$john = new Developer('John Doe', 12000);
$jane = new Designer('Jane', 10000);
// Add them to organization
$organization = new Organization();
$organization->addEmployee($john);
$organization->addEmployee($jane);
echo "Net salaries: " . $organization->getNetSalaries(); // Net Salaries: 22000Real world example
Imagine you run a car service shop offering multiple services. Now how do you calculate the bill to be charged? You pick one service and dynamically keep adding to it the prices for the provided services till you get the final cost. Here each type of service is a decorator.
In plain words
Decorator pattern lets you dynamically change the behavior of an object at run time by wrapping them in an object of a decorator class.
Wikipedia says
In object-oriented programming, the decorator pattern is a design pattern that allows behavior to be added to an individual object, either statically or dynamically, without affecting the behavior of other objects from the same class. The decorator pattern is often useful for adhering to the Single Responsibility Principle, as it allows functionality to be divided between classes with unique areas of concern.
Programmatic Example
Lets take coffee for example. First of all we have a simple coffee implementing the coffee interface
interface Coffee {
public function getCost();
public function getDescription();
}
class SimpleCoffee implements Coffee {
public function getCost() {
return 10;
}
public function getDescription() {
return 'Simple coffee';
}
}We want to make the code extensible to allow options to modify it if required. Lets make some add-ons (decorators)
class MilkCoffee implements Coffee {
protected $coffee;
public function __construct(Coffee $coffee) {
$this->coffee = $coffee;
}
public function getCost() {
return $this->coffee->getCost() + 2;
}
public function getDescription() {
return $this->coffee->getDescription() + ', milk';
}
}
class WhipCoffee implements Coffee {
protected $coffee;
public function __construct(Coffee $coffee) {
$this->coffee = $coffee;
}
public function getCost() {
return $this->coffee->getCost() + 5;
}
public function getDescription() {
return $this->coffee->getDescription() + ', whip';
}
}
class VanillaCoffee implements Coffee {
protected $coffee;
public function __construct(Coffee $coffee) {
$this->coffee = $coffee;
}
public function getCost() {
return $this->coffee->getCost() + 3;
}
public function getDescription() {
return $this->coffee->getDescription() + ', vanilla';
}
}Lets make a coffee now
$someCoffee = new SimpleCoffee();
echo $someCoffee->getCost(); // 10
echo $someCoffee->getDescription(); // Simple Coffee
$someCoffee = new MilkCoffee($someCoffee);
echo $someCoffee->getCost(); // 12
echo $someCoffee->getDescription(); // Simple Coffee, milk
$someCoffee = new WhipCoffee($someCoffee);
echo $someCoffee->getCost(); // 17
echo $someCoffee->getDescription(); // Simple Coffee, milk, whip
$someCoffee = new VanillaCoffee($someCoffee);
echo $someCoffee->getCost(); // 20
echo $someCoffee->getDescription(); // Simple Coffee, milk, whip, vanillaReal world example
How do you turn on the computer? "Hit the power button" you say! That is what you believe because you are using a simple interface that computer provides on the outside, internally it has to do a lot of stuff to make it happen. This simple interface to the complex subsystem is a facade.
In plain words
Facade pattern provides a simplified interface to a complex subsystem.
Wikipedia says
A facade is an object that provides a simplified interface to a larger body of code, such as a class library.
Programmatic Example Taking our computer example from above. Here we have the computer class
class Computer {
public function getElectricShock() {
echo "Ouch!";
}
public function makeSound() {
echo "Beep beep!";
}
public function showLoadingScreen() {
echo "Loading..";
}
public function bam() {
echo "Ready to be used!";
}
public function closeEverything() {
echo "Bup bup bup buzzzz!";
}
public function sooth() {
echo "Zzzzz";
}
public function pullCurrent() {
echo "Haaah!";
}
}Here we have the facade
class ComputerFacade
{
protected $computer;
public function __construct(Computer $computer) {
$this->computer = $computer;
}
public function turnOn() {
$this->computer->getElectricShock();
$this->computer->makeSound();
$this->computer->showLoadingScreen();
$this->computer->bam();
}
public function turnOff() {
$this->computer->closeEverything();
$this->computer->pullCurrent();
$this->computer->sooth();
}
}Now to use the facade
$computer = new ComputerFacade(new Computer());
$computer->turnOn(); // Ouch! Beep beep! Loading.. Ready to be used!
$compuer->turnOff(); // Bup bup buzzz! Haah! ZzzzzReal world example
Did you ever have fresh tea from some stall? They often make more than one cup that you demanded and save the rest for any other customer so to save the resources e.g. gas etc. Flyweight pattern is all about that i.e. sharing.
In plain words
It is used to minimize memory usage or computational expenses by sharing as much as possible with similar objects.
Wikipedia says
In computer programming, flyweight is a software design pattern. A flyweight is an object that minimizes memory use by sharing as much data as possible with other similar objects; it is a way to use objects in large numbers when a simple repeated representation would use an unacceptable amount of memory.
Programmatic example Translating our tea example from above. First of all we have tea types and tea maker
// Anything that will be cached is flyweight.
// Types of tea here will be flyweights.
class KarakTea {
}
// Acts as a factory and saves the tea
class TeaMaker {
protected $availableTea = [];
public function make($preference) {
if (empty($this->availableTea[$preference])) {
$this->availableTea[$preference] = new KarakTea();
}
return $this->availableTea[$preference];
}
}Then we have the TeaShop which takes orders and serves them
class TeaShop {
protected $orders;
protected $teaMaker;
public function __construct(TeaMaker $teaMaker) {
$this->teaMaker = $teaMaker;
}
public function takeOrder(string $teaType, int $table) {
$this->orders[$table] = $this->teaMaker->make($teaType);
}
public function serve() {
foreach($this->orders as $table => $tea) {
echo "Serving tea to table# " . $table;
}
}
}And it can be used as below
$shop = new TeaShop();
$shop->takeOrder('less sugar', 1);
$shop->takeOrder('more milk', 2);
$shop->takeOrder('without sugar', 5);
$shop->serve();
// Serving tea to table# 1
// Serving tea to table# 2
// Serving tea to table# 5Real world example
Have you ever used access card to enter a door? There are multiple options to open that door i.e. it can be opened either using access card or by pressing a button that bypasses the security. Here door's main functionality is to open but there is a proxy added on top of it to add some additional functionality to the door. Let me better explain it using the code example below.
In plain words
In proxy pattern a class represents the functionality of another class.
Wikipedia says
A proxy, in its most general form, is a class functioning as an interface to something else. A proxy is a wrapper or agent object that is being called by the client to access the real serving object behind the scenes. Use of the proxy can simply be forwarding to the real object, or can provide additional logic. In the proxy extra functionality can be provided, for example caching when operations on the real object are resource intensive, or checking preconditions before operations on the real object are invoked.
Programmatic Example Taking our security door example from above. Firstly we have the door interface and an implementation of door
interface Door {
public function open();
public function close();
}
class LabDoor implements Door {
public function open() {
echo "Opening lab door";
}
public function close() {
echo "Closing the lab door";
}
}Then we have a proxy to secure any doors that we want
class Security {
protected $door;
public function __construct(Door $door) {
$this->door = $door;
}
public function open($password) {
if ($this->authenticate($password)) {
$this->door->open();
} else {
echo "Big no! It ain't possible.";
}
}
public function authenticate($password) {
return $password === '$ecr@t'
}
public function close() {
$this->door->close();
}
}And here is how it can be used
$door = new Security(new LabDoor());
$door->open('invalid'); // Big no! It ain't possible.
$door->open('$ecr@t'); // Opening lab door
$door->close('Closing lab door');Yet another example would be some sort of data-mapper implementation. For example, I recently made an ODM (Object Data Mapper) for mongodb using this pattern where I wrote a proxy around mongo classes while utilizing the magic method __call. All the method calls were proxied to the original mongo class and result retrieved was returned as it is but in case of find or findOne data was mapped to the required class objects and the object was returned instead of Cursor.
In plain words
It is concerned with assignment of responsibilities between the objects. What makes them different from structural patterns is they don't just specify the structure but also outline the patterns for message passing/communication between them. Or in other words, they assist in answering "How to run a behavior in software component?"
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, behavioral design patterns are design patterns that identify common communication patterns between objects and realize these patterns. By doing so, these patterns increase flexibility in carrying out this communication.
- Chain of Responsibility
- Command
- Iterator
- Mediator
- Memento
- Observer
- Visitor
- Strategy
- State
- Template Method
Real world example
For example, you have three payment methods (
A,BandC) setup in your account; each having a different amount in it.Ahas 100 USD,Bhas 300 USD and C having 1000 USD and the preference for payments is chosen asAthenBthenC. You try to purchase something that is worth 210 USD. Using Chain of Responsibility, first of all accountAwill be checked if it can make the purchase, if yes purchase will be made and the chain will be broken. If not, request will move forward to accountBchecking for amount if yes chain will be broken otherwise the request will keep forwarding till it finds the suitable handler. HereA,BandCare links of the chain and the whole phenomenon is Chain of Responsibility.
In plain words
It helps building a chain of objects. Request enters from one end and keeps going from object to object till it finds the suitable handler.
Wikipedia says
In object-oriented design, the chain-of-responsibility pattern is a design pattern consisting of a source of command objects and a series of processing objects. Each processing object contains logic that defines the types of command objects that it can handle; the rest are passed to the next processing object in the chain.
Programmatic Example
Translating our account example above. First of all we have a base account having the logic for chaining the accounts together and some accounts
abstract class Account {
protected $successor;
protected $balance;
public function setNext(Account $account) {
$this->successor = $account;
}
public function pay(float $amountToPay) {
if ($this->canPay($amountToPay)) {
echo sprintf('Paid %s using %s' . PHP_EOL, $amount, get_called_class());
} else if ($this->successor) {
echo sprintf('Cannot pay using %s. Proceeding ..' . PHP_EOL, get_called_class());
$this->successor->pay($amountToPay);
} else {
throw Exception('None of the accounts have enough balance');
}
}
public function canPay($amount) : bool {
return $this->balance <= $amount;
}
}
class Bank extends Account {
protected $balance;
public function __construct(float $balance) {
$this->$balance = $balance;
}
}
class Paypal extends Account {
protected $balance;
public function __construct(float $balance) {
$this->$balance = $balance;
}
}
class Bitcoin extends Account {
protected $balance;
public function __construct(float $balance) {
$this->$balance = $balance;
}
}Now let's prepare the chain using the links defined above (i.e. Bank, Paypal, Bitcoin)
// Let's prepare a chain like below
// $bank->$paypal->$bitcoin
//
// First priority bank
// If bank can't pay then paypal
// If paypal can't pay then bit coin
$bank = new Bank(100); // Bank with balance 100
$paypal = new Paypal(200); // Paypal with balance 200
$bitcoin = new Bitcoin(300); // Bitcoin with balance 300
$bank->setNext($paypal);
$paypal->setNext($bitcoin);
// Let's try to pay using the first priority i.e. bank
$bank->pay(259);
// Output will be
// ==============
// Cannot pay using bank. Proceeding ..
// Cannot pay using paypal. Proceeding ..:
// Paid 259 using Bitcoin!Real world example
A generic example would be you ordering a food at restaurant. You (i.e.
Client) ask the waiter (i.e.Invoker) to bring some food (i.e.Command) and waiter simply forwards the request to Chef (i.e.Receiver) who has the knowledge of what and how to cook. Another example would be you (i.e.Client) switching on (i.e.Command) the television (i.e.Receiver) using a remote control (Invoker).
In plain words
Allows you to encapsulate actions in objects. The key idea behind this pattern is to provide the means to decouple client from receiver.
Wikipedia says
In object-oriented programming, the command pattern is a behavioral design pattern in which an object is used to encapsulate all information needed to perform an action or trigger an event at a later time. This information includes the method name, the object that owns the method and values for the method parameters.
Programmatic Example
First of all we have the receiver that has the implementation of every action that could be performed
// Receiver
class Bulb {
public function turnOn() {
echo "Bulb has been lit";
}
public function turnOff() {
echo "Darkness!";
}
}then we have an interface that each of the commands are going to implement and then we have a set of commands
interface Command {
public function execute();
public function undo();
public function redo();
}
// Command
class TurnOn implements Command {
protected $bulb;
public function __construct(Bulb $bulb) {
$this->bulb = $bulb;
}
public function execute() {
$this->bulb->turnOn();
}
public function undo() {
$this->bulb->turnOff();
}
public function redo() {
$this->execute();
}
}
class TurnOff implements Command {
protected $bulb;
public function __construct(Bulb $bulb) {
$this->bulb = $bulb;
}
public function execute() {
$this->bulb->turnOff();
}
public function undo() {
$this->bulb->turnOn();
}
public function redo() {
$this->execute();
}
}Then we have an Invoker with whom the client will interact to process any commands
// Invoker
class RemoteControl {
public function submit(Command $command) {
$command->execute();
}
}Finally let's see how we can use it in our client
$bulb = new Bulb();
$turnOn = new TurnOnCommand($bulb);
$turnOff = new TurnOffCommand($bulb);
$remote = new RemoteControl();
$remoteControl->submit($turnOn); // Bulb has been lit!
$remoteControl->submit($turnOff); // Darkness!Command pattern can also be used to implement a transaction based system. Where you keep maintaining the history of commands as soon as you execute them. If the final command is successfully executed, all good otherwise just iterate through the history and keep executing the undo on all the executed commands.
Real world example
An old radio set will be a good example of iterator, where user could start at some channel and then use next or previous buttons to go through the respective channels. Or take an example of MP3 player or a TV set where you could press the next and previous buttons to go through the consecutive channels or in other words they all provide an interface to iterate through the respective channels, songs or radio stations.
In plain words
It presents a way to access the elements of an object without exposing the underlying presentation.
Wikipedia says
In object-oriented programming, the iterator pattern is a design pattern in which an iterator is used to traverse a container and access the container's elements. The iterator pattern decouples algorithms from containers; in some cases, algorithms are necessarily container-specific and thus cannot be decoupled.
Programmatic example
In PHP it is quite easy to implement using SPL (Standard PHP Library). Translating our radio stations example from above. First of all we have RadioStation
class RadioStation {
protected $frequency;
public function __construct(float $frequency) {
$this->frequency = $frequency;
}
public function getFrequency() : float {
return $this->frequency;
}
}Then we have our iterator
use Countable;
use Iterator;
class StationList implements Countable, Iterator {
/** @var RadioStation[] $stations */
protected $stations = [];
/** @var int $counter */
protected $counter;
public function addStation(RadioStation $station) {
$this->stations[] = $station;
}
public funtion removeStation(RadioStation $toRemove) {
$toRemoveFrequency = $toRemove->getFrequency();
$this->stations = array_filter($this->stations, function (RadioStation $station) use ($toRemoveFrequency) {
return $station->getFrequency() !== $toRemoveFrequency;
});
}
public function count() : int {
return count($this->stations);
}
public function current() : RadioStation {
return $this->stations[$this->counter];
}
public function key() {
return $this->counter;
}
public function next() {
$this->counter++;
}
public function rewind() {
$this->counter = 0;
}
public function valid(): bool
{
return isset($this->stations[$this->counter]);
}
}And then it can be used as
$stationList = new StationList();
$stationList->addStation(new Station(89));
$stationList->addStation(new Station(101));
$stationList->addStation(new Station(102));
$stationList->addStation(new Station(103.2));
foreach($stationList as $station) {
echo $station->getFrequency() . PHP_EOL;
}
$stationList->removeStation(new Station(89)); // Will remove station 89Real world example
A general example would be when you talk to someone on your mobile phone, there is a network provider sitting between you and them and your conversation goes through it instead of being directly sent. In this case network provider is mediator.
In plain words
Mediator pattern adds a third party object (called mediator) to control the interaction between two objects (called colleagues). It helps reduce the coupling between the classes communicating with each other. Because now they don't need to have the knowledge of each other's implementation.
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, the mediator pattern defines an object that encapsulates how a set of objects interact. This pattern is considered to be a behavioral pattern due to the way it can alter the program's running behavior.
Programmatic Example
Here is the simplest example of a chat room (i.e. mediator) with users (i.e. colleagues) sending messages to each other.
First of all, we have the mediator i.e. the chat room
// Mediator
class ChatRoom implements ChatRoomMediator {
public function showMessage(User $user, string $message) {
$time = date('M d, y H:i');
$sender = $user->getName();
echo $time . '[' . $sender . ']:' . $message;
}
}Then we have our users i.e. colleagues
class User {
protected $name;
protected $chatMediator;
public function __construct(string $name, ChatRoomMediator $chatMediator) {
$this->name = $name;
$this->chatMediator = $chatMediator;
}
public function getName() {
return $this->name;
}
public function send($message) {
$this->chatMediator->showMessage($this, $message);
}
}And the usage
$mediator = new ChatRoom();
$john = new User('John Doe', $mediator);
$jane = new User('Jane Doe', $mediator);
$john->send('Hi there!');
$jane->send('Hey!');
// Output will be
// Feb 14, 10:58 [John]: Hi there!
// Feb 14, 10:58 [Jane]: Hey!Real world example
Take the example of calculator (i.e. originator), where whenever you perform some calculation the last calculation is saved in memory (i.e. memento) so that you can get back to it and maybe get it restored using some action buttons (i.e. caretaker).
In plain words
Memento pattern is about capturing and storing the current state of an object in a manner that it can be restored later on in a smooth manner.
Wikipedia says
The memento pattern is a software design pattern that provides the ability to restore an object to its previous state (undo via rollback).
Usually useful when you need to provide some sort of undo functionality.
Programmatic Example
Lets take an example of text editor which keeps saving the state from time to time and that you can restore if you want.
First of all we have our memento object that will be able to hold the editor state
class EditorMemento {
protected $content;
public function __construct(string $content) {
$this->content = $content;
}
public function getContent() {
return $this->content;
}
}Then we have our editor i.e. originator that is going to use memento object
class Editor {
protected $content = '';
public function type(string $words) {
$this->content = $this->content . ' ' . $words;
}
public function getContent() {
return $this->content;
}
public function save() {
return new EditorMemento($this->content);
}
public function restore(EditorMemento $memento) {
$this->content = $memento->getContent();
}
}And then it can be used as
$editor = new Editor();
// Type some stuff
$editor->type('This is the first sentence.');
$editor->type('This is second.');
// Save the state to restore to : This is the first sentence. This is second.
$saved = $editor->save();
// Type some more
$editor->type('And this is third.');
// Output: Content before Saving
echo $editor->getContent(); // This is the first sentence. This is second. And this is third.
// Restoring to last saved state
$editor->restore($saved);
$editor->getContent(); // This is the first sentence. This is second.Real world example
A good example would be the job seekers where they subscribe to some job posting site and they are notified whenever there is a matching job opportunity.
In plain words
Defines a dependency between objects so that whenever an object changes its state, all its dependents are notified.
Wikipedia says
The observer pattern is a software design pattern in which an object, called the subject, maintains a list of its dependents, called observers, and notifies them automatically of any state changes, usually by calling one of their methods.
Programmatic example
Translating our example from above. First of all we have job seekers that need to be notified for a job posting
class JobPost {
protected $title;
public function __construct(string $title) {
$this->title = $title;
}
public function getTitle() {
return $this->title;
}
}
class JobSeeker implements Observer {
protected $name;
public function __construct(string $name) {
$this->name = $name;
}
public function onJobPosted(JobPosting $job) {
// Do something with the job posting
echo 'Hi ' . $this->name . '! New job posted: '. $job->getTitle();
}
}Then we have our job postings to which the job seekers will subscribe
class JobPostings implements Observable {
protected $observers = [];
protected function notify(JobPost $jobPosting) {
foreach ($this->observers as $observer) {
$observer->onJobPosted($jobPosting);
}
}
public function attach(Observer $observer) {
$this->observers[] = $observer;
}
public function addJob(JobPost $jobPosting) {
$this->notify($jobPosting);
}
}Then it can be used as
// Create subscribers
$johnDoe = new JobSeeker('John Doe');
$janeDoe = new JobSeeker('Jane Doe');
$kaneDoe = new JobSeeker('Kane Doe');
// Create publisher and attach subscribers
$jobPostings = new JobPostings();
$jobPostings->attatch($johnDoe);
$jobPostings->attatch($janeDoe);
// Add a new job and see if subscribers get notified
$jobPostings->addJob(new JobPost('Software Engineer'));
// Output
// Hi John Doe! New job posted: Software Engineer
// Hi Jane Doe! New job posted: Software EngineerReal world example
Consider someone visiting Dubai. They just need a way (i.e. visa) to enter Dubai. After arrival, they can come and visit any place in Dubai on their own without having to ask for permission or to do some leg work in order to visit any place here; just let them know of a place and they can visit it. Visitor pattern let's you do just that, it helps you add places to visit so that they can visit as much as they can without having to do any legwork.
In plain words
Visitor pattern let's you add further operations to objects without having to modify them.
Wikipedia says
In object-oriented programming and software engineering, the visitor design pattern is a way of separating an algorithm from an object structure on which it operates. A practical result of this separation is the ability to add new operations to existing object structures without modifying those structures. It is one way to follow the open/closed principle.
Programmatic example
Let's take an example of a zoo simulation where we have several different kinds of animals and we have to make them Sound. Let's translate this using visitor pattern
// Visitee
interface Animal {
public function accept(AnimalOperation $operation);
}
// Visitor
interface AnimalOperation {
public function visitMonkey(Monkey $monkey);
public function visitLion(Lion $lion);
public function visitDolphin(Dolphin $dolphin);
}Then we have our implementations for the animals
class Monkey {
public function shout() {
echo 'Ooh oo aa aa!';
}
public function accept(AnimalOperation $operation) {
$operation->visitMonkey($this);
}
}
class Lion {
public function roar() {
echo 'Roaaar!';
}
public function accept(AnimalOperation $operation) {
$operation->visitLion($this);
}
}
class Dolphin {
public function speak() {
echo 'Tuut tuttu tuutt!';
}
public function accept(AnimalOperation $operation) {
$operation->visitDolphin($this);
}
}Let's implement our visitor
class Speak implements AnimalOperation {
public function visitMonkey(Monkey $monkey) {
$monkey->shout();
}
public function visitLion(Lion $lion) {
$lion->roar();
}
public function visitDolphin(Dolphin $dolphin) {
$dolphin->speak();
}
}And then it can be used as
$monkey = new Monkey();
$lion = new Lion();
$dolphin = new Dolphin();
$speak = new Speak();
$monkey->accept($speak); // Ooh oo aa aa!
$lion->accept($speak); // Roaaar!
$dolphin->accept($speak); // Tuut tutt tuutt!We could have done this simply by having a inheritance hierarchy for the animals but then we would have to modify the animals whenever we would have to add new actions to animals. But now we will not have to change them. For example, let's say we are asked to add the jump behavior to the animals, we can simply add that by creating a new visitor i.e.
class Jump implements AnimalOperation {
public function visitMonkey(Monkey $monkey) {
echo 'Jumped 20 feet high! on to the tree!';
}
public function visitLion(Lion $lion) {
echo 'Jumped 7 feet! Back on the ground!';
}
public function visitDolphin(Dolphin $dolphin) {
echo 'Walked on water a little and disappeared';
}
}And for the usage
$jump = new Jump();
$monkey->accept($speak); // Ooh oo aa aa!
$monkey->accept($jump); // Jumped 20 feet high! on to the tree!
$lion->accept($speak); // Roaaar!
$lion->accept($jump); // Jumped 7 feet! Back on the ground!
$dolphin->accept($speak); // Tuut tutt tuutt!
$dolphin->accept($jump); // Walked on water a little and disappearedReal world example
Consider the example of sorting, we implemented bubble sort but the data started to grow and bubble sort started getting very slow. In order to tackle this we implemented Quick sort. But now although the quick sort algorithm was doing better for large datasets, it was very slow for smaller datasets. In order to handle this we implemented a strategy where for small datasets, bubble sort will be used and for larger, quick sort.
In plain words
Strategy pattern allows you to switch the algorithm or strategy based upon the situation.
Wikipedia says
In computer programming, the strategy pattern (also known as the policy pattern) is a behavioural software design pattern that enables an algorithm's behavior to be selected at runtime.
Programmatic example
Translating our example from above. First of all we have our strategy interface and different strategy implementations
interface SortStrategy {
public function sort(array $dataset) : array;
}
class BubbleSortStrategy {
public function sort(array $dataset) : array {
echo "Sorting using bubble sort";
// Do sorting
return $dataset;
}
}
class QuickSortStrategy {
public function sort(array $dataset) : array {
echo "Sorting using quick sort";
// Do sorting
return $dataset;
}
}And then we have our client that is going to use any strategy
class Sorter {
protected $sorter;
public function __construct(SortStrategy $sorter) {
$this->sorter = $sorter;
}
public function sort(array $dataset) : array {
return $this->sorter->sort($dataset);
}
}And it can be used as
$dataset = [1, 5, 4, 3, 2, 8];
$sorter = new Sorter(new BubbleSortStrategy());
$sorter->sort($dataset); // Output : Sorting using bubble sort
$sorter = new Sorter(new QuickSortStrategy());
$sorter->sort($dataset); // Output : Sorting using quick sortReal world example
Imagine you are using some drawing application, you choose the paint brush to draw. Now the brush changes it's behavior based on the selected color i.e. if you have chosen red color it will draw in red, if blue then it will be in blue etc.
In plain words
It lets you change the behavior of a class when the state changes.
Wikipedia says
The state pattern is a behavioral software design pattern that implements a state machine in an object-oriented way. With the state pattern, a state machine is implemented by implementing each individual state as a derived class of the state pattern interface, and implementing state transitions by invoking methods defined by the pattern's superclass. The state pattern can be interpreted as a strategy pattern which is able to switch the current strategy through invocations of methods defined in the pattern's interface
Programmatic example
Let's take an example of text editor, it let's you change the state of text that is typed i.e. if you have selected bold, it starts writing in bold, if italic then in italics etc.
First of all we have our state interface and some state implementations
interface WritingState {
public function write(string $words);
}
class UpperCase implements WritingState {
public function write(string $words) {
echo strtoupper($words);
}
}
class LowerCase implements WritingState {
public function write(string $words) {
echo strtolower($words);
}
}
class Default implements WritingState {
public function write(string $words) {
echo $words;
}
}Then we have our editor
class TextEditor {
protected $state;
public function __construct(WritingState $state) {
$this->state = $state;
}
public function setState(WritingState $state) {
$this->state = $state;
}
public function type(string $words) {
$this->state->write($words);
}
}And then it can be used as
$editor = new TextEditor(new Default());
$editor->type('First line');
$editor->setState(new UpperCaseState());
$editor->type('Second line');
$editor->type('Third line');
$editor->setState(new LowerCaseState());
$editor->type('Fourth line');
$editor->type('Fifth line');
// Output:
// First line
// SECOND LINE
// THIRD LINE
// fourth line
// fifth lineReal world example
Suppose we are getting some house built. The steps for building might look like
- Prepare the base of house
- Build the walls
- Add roof
- Add other floors The order of these steps could never be changed i.e. you can't build the roof before building the walls etc but each of the steps could be modified for example walls can be made of wood or polyester or stone.
In plain words
Template method defines the skeleton of how certain algorithm could be performed but defers the implementation of those steps to the children classes.
Wikipedia says
In software engineering, the template method pattern is a behavioral design pattern that defines the program skeleton of an algorithm in an operation, deferring some steps to subclasses. It lets one redefine certain steps of an algorithm without changing the algorithm's structure.
Programmatic Example
Imagine we have a build tool that helps us test, lint, build, generate build reports (i.e. code coverage reports, linting report etc) and deploy our app on the test server.
First of all we have our base class that specifies the skeleton for the build algorithm
abstract class Builder {
// Template method
public final function build() {
$this->test();
$this->lint();
$this->assemble();
$this->deploy();
}
public abstract function test();
public abstract function lint();
public abstract function build();
public abstract function deploy();
}Then we can have our implementations
class AndroidBuilder extends Builder {
public function test() {
echo 'Running android tests';
}
public function lint() {
echo 'Linting the android code';
}
public function assemble() {
echo 'Assembling the android build';
}
public function deploy() {
echo 'Deploying android build to server';
}
}
class IosBuilder extends Builder {
public function test() {
echo 'Running ios tests';
}
public function lint() {
echo 'Linting the ios code';
}
public function assemble() {
echo 'Assembling the ios build';
}
public function deploy() {
echo 'Deploying ios build to server';
}
}And then it can be used as
$androidBuilder = new AndroidBuilder();
$androidBuilder->build();
// Output:
// Running android tests
// Linting the android code
// Assembling the android build
// Deploying android build to server
$iosBuilder = new IosBuilder();
$iosBuilder->build();
// Output:
// Running ios tests
// Linting the ios code
// Assembling the ios build
// Deploying ios build to serverAnd that about wraps it up. I will continue to improve this, so you might want to watch/star this repository to revisit. Also, I have plans on writing the same about the architectural patterns, stay tuned for it.
- Report issues
- Open pull request with improvements
- Spread the word
- Reach out to me directly at kamranahmed.se@gmail.com or @kamranahmedse
MIT © Kamran Ahmed