mechmotum/ollie-optimization

Incomplete citation

Closed this issue · 8 comments

Johnny (2013) Skateboarding Is My
Lifetime Sport: DECK LENGTH
MEASURING BY COMPANY. URL
http://skateboardingismylifetimesport.
blogspot.com/2013/05/
deck-length-measuring-by-company.html

Only first name. Just a URL. Not really an good citation. All caps.

I can't even open the URL:

image

Note that I have manually edited the bib file extensively to try to correct all the issues with the references. So don't overwrite with a zotero export.

I still have a copy of the page but it seems that it is taken down... The page consisted of a person that emailed all big skateboarding companies how they measure the skateboard. Maybe it isn't a reliable source. What would be the right thing to solve it? Should this necessarily be backed up by a citation?

The claim that is being made is:
"Boards are measured differently by each brand"

My suggestion is to get rid of this part and the citation. The rest part of the sentence is still backed up by a citation and might be enough to make the point:

"non-specific descriptions such as mellow, steep, and
wide are usually used to communicate deck dimensions to customers"

See pdf attached of local saved website for info on the source.
deck-length-measuring-by-company.pdf

I think we can just remove the citation but I don't think that "boards are measured differently by each brand" needs to have proof. We can probably leave it, just remove the citation.

Agreed, I will remove it now

Citation is gone